*HIGHLIGHT OF NIGHT* 1850 Baldwin & Co $5 California Gold, K-2 R-5+ Graded ms61 details By SEGS (fc)

View Item in Catalog
  Lot #478  (Sale Order: 323 of 583)  
This lot was not sold.
Reserve Not Met
"Tax, Shipping & Handling and Internet Premium not included. See Auction Information for full details."

Payment Type:

Payment Type: Please Add / Select Card

Description Terms of Sale
Item Description: Translate description
***Auction Highlight*** 1850 Baldwin & Co $5 California Gold, K-2 R-5+ Graded ms61 details By SEGS. HIGHLIGHT OF THE NIGHT, Up for Auction is an Ultra Rare Uncirculated Baldwin & Co. $5 Half Eagle. One of only 3 Known Uncirculated examples to have survived, the highest of which is graded ms61.. George Baldwin and Thomas Holman established a jewelry and watchmaking concern on Clay Street in San Francisco in 1849. Shortly afterward, they purchased F.D. Kohler's profitable coining operation, as he was preparing for his new position as assayer for the newly established California State Assay Office. Baldwin & Co. began issuing coins in five, ten, and twenty dollar denominations, which were initially well-received by merchants and bankers like Dunbar's Banking and Exchange Office and Tucker & Reeve, jewelers. According to Donald Kagin, Albert Kuner engraved the dies for the Baldwin coinage. Henry Chapman gave a good description of the 1850 Baldwin & Co. five dollar gold piece, designated as the K-2 variety in Kagin's Private Gold Coins and Patterns of the United States, in lot 1862 of his catalog of the Matthew Stickney Collection (Chapman, 6/1907):"1850 $5. Head of Liberty with BALDWIN & CO., around 13 stars, below 1850. R. Eagle with olive branch in right talon, three arrows in left talon. S. M. V. (Standard Mint Value) CALIFORNIA GOLD, below FIVE DOL. Border beaded, edge milled. Very fine. Excessively rare, probably only about five known. See plate." Unfortunately, Baldwin's coins were found to contain less than face value in gold when assayed by Augustus Humbert at the United States Assay Office in March of 1851. The five dollar pieces had an average intrinsic value of $4.91 according to Humbert's findings. The assay was undertaken at the request of journalist James King of William, who was also a rival of Baldwin & Co. in the private coinage business and obviously had an axe to grind in the affair. Humbert himself was not a disinterested party, as Baldwin & Co. was the only private mint to nearly match the output of the Assay Office in its most productive years, 1850 and 1851. Baldwin claimed there was a plot by competitors to discredit his coins, and a later assay at the Philadelphia Mint was much more favorable in its findings, but there was an immediate backlash in the local press, and the public lost all confidence in the Baldwin & Co. coinage. Baldwin was forced to flee the territory in the face of this public outrage, and greedy merchants only accepted his coins at a steep discount, to be profitably turned in for recoinage at the Assay Office. By December of 1851, few Baldwin & Co. coins were still in circulation. Although the Baldwin & Co. five dollar gold piece is not as elusive today as it was in Henry Chapman's time, it is still quite rare. In fact, true Uncirculated examples are extremely rare, with less than a handful known. PCGS, SEGS & NGC list a combined total of 29 coins in their population tables, including an unknown number of resubmissions and crossovers. Territorial enthusiasts prize the Baldwin & Co. coins in all grades and conditions, and will no doubt seize this exceptional opportunity. The present coin is an attractive MS61 Details example, with vivid orange-gold surfaces. Kagin notes this color indicates the presence of copper alloy in the native California gold. The design elements are sharply detailed and an often-seen die crack runs through the letters MV and the wingtip on the reverse. Some specimens of the K-2 variety show a heavy die break and cud on the obverse rim at star 12, but this coin was struck before that crack developed. The surfaces show some effects of die rust, in the form of tiny circular lumps on the fields, especially on the upper reverse. The few light marks by the eagles head, which can only be seen under high magnification is my guess as to the reason for the details grade, as I can see no overt signs anywhere else, and can easily see this in a straight graded holder. A number of minor contact marks are evident on the pleasing surfaces, but none are large or distracting individually. The overall presentation is most attractive for this rare Territorial gold issue. I will note that ms61 is the finest known. I have included a picture of another ms61 example, it realized $82,250 in 2014. A Corey's Pick, Bid to Win, Don't let it get Away, you might not find its equal Coin. I give this coin my highest recommendation

Unable to retrieve AutoCheck Summary Report, please try back later.

Summary Vehicle History Report below provided by AutoCheck.

AutoCheck® vehicle history reports deliver information on reported accidents, odometer rollback, lemon vehicles, branded titles and much more.

AutoCheck found record(s) for this   




Get the full report to learn more:

Know the exact vehicle you want? One report may be all you need.  Single Report $24.99

Researching more than one vehicle? Run as many reports as you like for 21 days Unlimited Reports for 21 Days $44.99
This item is part of Breathtaking Spring Coin Consigns Auction 6 of 6
 Thursday, Jun 17, 2021 | 5:45 PM  Eastern
Print This Page

*HIGHLIGHT OF NIGHT* 1850 Baldwin & Co $5 California Gold, K-2 R-5+ Graded ms61 details By SEGS (fc)
*HIGHLIGHT OF NIGHT* 1850 Baldwin & Co $5 California Gold, K-2 R-5+ Graded ms61 details By SEGS (fc)
Lot number: 478
Seller: Key Date Coins
Event: Breathtaking Spring Coin Consigns Auction 6 of 6
Ends: Thursday, June 17 | 5:45 PM  Eastern

Message: 500 characters remaining