Premier Firearms Auction - Day 3
Premier Firearms Auction - Day 3
See Special Terms for additional fees
Cash Payment Discount: 3.5%
Description
Framed "American Horses Camp at Cheyenne Reservation" Print
Lot # 3125 (Sale Order: 126 of 606)
L.A. Huffman (1835-1931), an immensely influential and historically important frontier photographer of the American West, documented Montana's cowboys, ranchers, landscapes and native populations in their natural states. "View of Camp of Cheyenne Chief, American Horse," was taken circa 1889 and is housed in a 26 1/4 inches by 30 3/8 inch frame with double gold borders. The print portrays the view of Chief American Horse's camp with teepees on the vast, grass-covered, American prairie with accompanying horses in the background. Chief American Horse was a well-respected scout in the United States Army and the son of the famed Sitting Bear. American Horse signed a treaty in 1887 and led the delegation to Washington, D.C in 1891. He was proponent of creating positive relations between whites and the natives, and helped with the founding of the Carlisle School in Pennsylvania. The work is unsigned and on the back of the frame is marked "American Horse's Camp/at Cheyenne Reservation"
Class: Other
Very fine with some light handling marks on the frame and a clear image with a small stain in the lower right corner.
Provenance: The John Fox Collection
Presentation U.S. Marshals Badge Inscribed to James Fagan
Lot # 3126 (Sale Order: 127 of 606)
Offered here is a historic 14k gold presentation United States Marshal badge with seven diamonds. The presentation inscription on the back reads, "PRESENTED BY/WIFE AND FRIENDS TO/JIM FAGAN/FT. SMITH ARK./1875." Comes in a period velvet lined presentation case. During the Civil War, James Fagan (1828-1893) was a major general in the Confederate Army. His brigade composed of Arkansas regiments played key roles in the Battle of Helena, the successful defense of Little Rock and the Red River campaign of 1864. For his exemplary service in the Red River campaign that helped to drive Union forces out of southern Arkansas, he was promoted to major general in April 1864 and commanded an Arkansas cavalry division that met its demise during Price's Raid into Missouri and the Battle of Mine Creek. At war's end Fagan was commander of the District of Arkansas. Fagan served as the commander of Joseph Brooks' militia during the Brooks-Baxter War of Arkansas in 1874, an armed conflict in Little Rock between factions of the Republican Party disputing the 1872 gubernatorial election. He was appointed U.S. Marshal for the Western District of Arkansas by President Ulysses S. Grant on July 2, 1874, no more than a year before the badge was presented to him. Fagan's career as a Marshal at Fort Smith coincided with the famed tenure of "Hanging Judge" Isaac Parker. Judge Parker served for two terms as a U.S. Congressman for Missouri's 7th congressional district (1871-1875) and served on the U.S. District Court for the Western District of Arkansas from Fort Smith for the next 21 years. He went by the moniker the "Hanging Judge." During his 21 years on the bench, Judge Parker tried 13,490 cases of which 344 were capital crimes. He sentenced 160 men to death by hanging (79 actually hanged for their crimes; the remaining died in jail, appealed or were pardoned). Fagan is known to have read at least six felons their death warrants. Speaking to Fagan's merits as a Marshal, the Oklahoma Star "ventur[ed] to say that nine-tenths of [us] would rather see him in the position than any man that could be appointed." The Marshals office for the Western District of Arkansas was, as the Star proclaimed, "the most vital importance to us. In fact we are dependent solely upon it for the preservation of our lives and our property."
Class: Other
Exceptionally fine overall with all diamonds secured in their fittings and clear inscription. The case is very fine showing scattered wear on both the interior and exterior. A unique piece of American history!
New York Engraved .44 Rimfire Antique Colt Single Action Army
Lot # 3127 (Sale Order: 128 of 606)
The included factory letter lists this revolver in .44 Rimfire with a 7 1/2 inch barrel, blue finish, and wood grips when part of a 50 gun shipment to Schuyler, Hartley & Graham in New York City on November 30, 1877. This revolver is one of only 1,863 Colt chambered in .44 Rimfire, and surviving examples are very scarce. This revolver is especially interesting as it was subsequently period shortened to a 5 1/2 inch barrel, engraved, fitted with a deluxe grip, and converted to centerfire. The engraving may have been engraved by legendary New York based master engraver L.D. Nimschke and is primarily classic American scrollwork with beaded backgrounds and also includes checkerboard and dot patterns, "Nimschke stars", and line and dot accents. The barrel has a blade front sight and the one-line "-COLTS PT. F.A. MFG. Co HARTFORD. CT. U.S.A.-" address. The frame has the two-line 1871 and 1872 patent marking on the left, and the left side of the trigger guard at the rear has "44 CAL" in an oval panel. The loading gate has assembly number "450", and the matching serial number "853" is visible on the frame, trigger guard, and butt.
Class: Antique
Very good as period retailer engraved with 50% nickel plating remaining, smooth dark gray and brown patina on the balance, distinct engraving and markings, a replacement custom engraved cylinder converted to centerfire, and general moderate overall wear suggesting real period use. The grip is also very good and has attractive aged patina, numerous small age lines, and minor wear. Mechanically fine.
Factory Engraved Colt Sheriff's Model 1877 Lightning Revolver
Lot # 3128 (Sale Order: 129 of 606)
Factory engraved Colt Model 1877 Lightning revolvers are a rarity. According to Colt historian R.L. Wilson, "factory records indicate approximately 250 Lightnings in .38 caliber [were engraved]" and "their usual finish was nickel plating." The included factory letter confirms the 3 1/2 inch barrel in .38 caliber, nickel finish, engraving, and grip material and states the revolver was shipped on August 18, 1879, to famed B. Kittredge & Co. of Cincinnati, Ohio. This was a six gun shipment. The engraving consists of floral scroll work on a stippled background along with flourishes of various motifs such as entwining lines and cross hatching. The barrel has the two-line Hartford address on top and the highly desirable acid etched "COLT DA 38" panel on the left side. The left side of the frame has the patent date marking (very faint). "38 CAL" is stamped on the left side of the trigger guard.
Class: Antique
Fine, retaining 60% original nickel plating with a smooth gray patina on the balance. The etched panel is faint. The engraving is crisp. The slightly age shrunken period replacement grips are also fine some handling marks and attractive grain and color. Mechanically excellent. A rarity in Colt collecting, this factory engraved Sheriff's Model 1877 Lightning revolver will be a welcome addition to even the most advanced collections.
Browning Bros. "Bull's Head Mexican Loop" Holster Rig
Lot # 3129 (Sale Order: 130 of 606)
Manufactured in the late 1800s to early 1900s, this is a desirable example of a "Bull's Head Mexican Loop" holster from the famous Ogden, Utah, shop of John Moses and Matthew Sandefur Browning. The Browning Brothers, particularly John Moses, were made famous by their various legendary firearms designs including multiple Winchester lever actions and Colt automatics. This holster shows the clear Browning Brothers cartouche and the popular bull's head design on the large retention loop, a design which began gaining popularity in the 1890s. The loop, body, and apron of the holster have some period-added brass tacks, a popular form of extra decoration during the period of use. The toe also appears to show period modification with part of the seam being opened, possibly for drainage. The holster will accommodate a 4 3/4 inch barreled Colt Single Action Army. Includes an unmarked cartridge belt that has a single row of cartridge loops for .44 or .45 caliber cartridges and a nickeled buckle. The belt is 1 5/8 inches wide and approximately 40 1/4 inches long.
Class: Other
Good, the holster showing some moderate wear and interesting period modifications (see above). The belt is also fine with moderate wear, some scattered scuffing, and age-related cracking. A desirable Browning Bros. holster rig that has the look of having spent time on the Frontier!
Presentation Pre-War/Post-War Colt Single Action Army Revolver
Lot # 3130 (Sale Order: 131 of 606)
Colt "Pre-War/Post-War" Single Action Army revolvers are highly prized among collectors. In 1948, this exceptional example was was presented by Colt Vice President Benjamin Conner to a U.S. Ordnance Department official. According to "Colt's Single Action Army Revolver Pre-War/Post-War Model" by Don Wilkerson, there were only 338 pre-World War II manufactured Colt Single Action revolvers assembled after World War II, which comprise the group of revolvers referred to as Pre-War/Post-War by collectors (page 19). This revolver is one of only 162 produced in this configuration and one of only 41 Pre-War/Post-War Models presented or gifted by the Colt factory in 1948 (page 35). The revolver is well documented as one of two SAAs Colt Vice President Benjamin Conner presented to two U.S. Ordnance Department officials. See the following lot for the other revolver. The factory letter confirms the revolver was charged to “Arms Selling Expense”, delivered to Vice President Benjamin Conner at the Hartford factory, and was for U.S. Ordnance Department officials Major Forsythe or William Bonkmeyer. This was a two gun shipment dated May 26, 1948 with the revolver configuration listed as a 5 ½ inch barrel in .38 caliber with finish and type of stocks not listed. Additional confirmation comes from the included scan of the original stock order for both guns. This stock order also confirms the barrel length, caliber, and charge to Arms Selling Expense as well as Major Forsythe and Mr. William Bonkmeyer of the Ordnance Department as the recipients of the two SAAs. In his accompanying 1978 dated letter (copy) noted Colt historian and author John Kopec provided additional details concerning the two SAAs: “The revolver #357,605 was given to William Bonkmeyer (sic) and #357,411 was presented to Major Forsythe…They are indeed a very interesting and significant pair…” These two SAAs are referenced in “A Study of the Colt Single Action Army Revolver” on page 189. This Pre-War/Post War SAA is certainly a well-documented piece of Colt history and a rare opportunity to acquire two historical presentation Colts on the same factory order! The barrel is marked with the one-line Hartford address on top and "COLT SINGLE ACTION ARMY 38 SPECIAL" on the left side. The left side of the frame has the two-line patent dates marking followed by a Rampant Colt. The left side of the trigger guard has the Colt factory triangle proof and "F," indicating it was assembled by Colt Master Gunsmith Harry St. John. The matching assembly number “161” appears on the loading gate and rear of the frame. The matching full serial number appears on the frame, trigger guard, back strap, and both grip panels. The matching partial serial number “11” is stamped on the rear face of the cylinder. The original Colt box is numbered to the gun. Also includes a bore brush.
Class: Curio & Relic Handgun
Excellent plus, retaining 99% plus original blue and vivid case colors with very limited handling marks. The grips are near new with crisp checkering. Mechanically excellent. The box is very fine. An, outstanding, highly sought after, well-documented presentation Pre-War/Post War Colt SAA worthy of the finest collection
Presentation Pre-War/Post-War Colt Single Action Army Revolver
Lot # 3131 (Sale Order: 132 of 606)
This highly sought after Colt "Pre-War/Post-War" Single Action Army revolver was assembled after World War II using pre-war manufactured parts, and in 1948 was presented by Colt Vice President Benjamin Conner to a U.S. Ordnance Department official. According to "Colt's Single Action Army Revolver Pre-War/Post-War Model" by Don Wilkerson, there were only 338 pre-World War II manufactured Colt Single Action revolvers assembled after World War II, which comprise the group of revolvers referred to as Pre-War/Post-War by collectors (page 19). This revolver is one of only 162 produced in this configuration and one of only 41 Pre-War/Post-War Models presented or gifted by the Colt factory in 1948 (page 35). The revolver is well documented as one of two SAAs Colt Vice President Benjamin Conner presented to two U.S. Ordnance Department officials. See the previous lot for the other revolver. The factory letter confirms the revolver was charged to “Arms Selling Expense”, delivered to Vice President Benjamin Conner at the Hartford factory, and was for U.S. Ordnance Department officials Major Forsythe or William Bonkmeyer. This was a two gun shipment dated May 26, 1948 with the revolver configuration listed as a 5 ½ inch barrel in .38 caliber with finish and type of stocks not listed. Additional confirmation comes from the included and rare original stock order for both guns. This original stock order also confirms the barrel length, caliber, and charge to Arms Selling Expense as well as Major Forsythe and Mr. William Bonkmeyer of the Ordnance Department as the recipients of the two SAAs. In his accompanying 1978 dated letter noted Colt historian and author John Kopec provided additional details concerning the two SAAs: “The revolver #357,605 was given to William Bonkmeyer (sic) and #357,411 was presented to Major Forsythe…They are indeed a very interesting and significant pair…” These two SAAs are referenced in “A Study of the Colt Single Action Army Revolver” on page 189 with this revolver, no. 357605, pictured. This Pre-War/Post War SAA is certainly a well-documented piece of Colt history and a rare opportunity to acquire two historical presentation Colts on the same factory order! The barrel is marked with the one-line Hartford address on top and "COLT SINGLE ACTION ARMY 38 SPECIAL" on the left side. The left side of the frame has the two-line patent dates marking followed by a Rampant Colt. The left side of the trigger guard has the Colt factory triangle proof and "F," indicating it was assembled by Colt Master Gunsmith Harry St. John. The matching assembly number “322” appears on the loading gate and rear of the frame. The matching full serial number appears on the frame, trigger guard, and back strap. The matching partial serial number “05” is stamped on the rear face of the cylinder. The original Colt box is numbered to the gun. Also includes the original test target and bore brush.
Class: Curio & Relic Handgun
Excellent plus, retaining 99% plus original blue and case colors with very limited handling marks. The grips are near new with crisp checkering. Mechanically excellent. The box is very fine. An extraordinary presentation documented Pre-War/Post-War SAA revolver that is a must have for the serious Colt collector.
Colt Single Action Army Revolver with Skeleton Stock
Lot # 3132 (Sale Order: 133 of 606)
This black powder frame SAA was manufactured in 1876 and comes with a highly sought after and rare Colt production skeletonized stock. The nearly impossible to find skeleton stock is a prized collectible missing from even the most advanced SAA collections. The stock attaches to the revolver via a special extended hammer screw projecting from both sides of the frame. These rare stocks were offered as accessories and there are no known records for how many, if any, were sold directly with Single Action Army Revolvers, other than Buntline Specials. Knowledgeable collectors have concluded that a limited number were produced. Records and examples discussed in "A Study of the Colt Single Action Army Revolvers" (see pages 8, 12, and 50) demonstrate that these stocks were particularly popular in England. Two lengths of the skeletonized stock as well as additional extended frame screws were shipped to Colt's dealers in England in the mid-1870s. The attachable stock offered here lacks visible markings and has a nickel plated finish and a blued adjustment nut. The skeleton shoulder stock was introduced in 1876 at the Philadelphia Centennial Exposition and an example was included on the Colt-Hartley & Graham display board of 1877. The accompanying factory letter states the revolver was shipped on February 28, 1876 to J.P. Moores Sons of New York City in .45 caliber chambering and blue finish with barrel length and type of stocks not listed, a common indication of a 7 1/2 inch barrel and walnut stocks which were standard for the period. This shipment was for 50 guns. The letter goes on to state, "The records also contain a second listing for this serial number that indicates the same configuration with shipment to Winchester Repeating Arms Company in New Haven, Connecticut on June 1, 1878." This specific example was actually shipped to Winchester, as documented in the factory letter, furthering its desirability. During the period the large manufacturers, including Colt and Winchester, often ordered arms from the other to supply their preferred large retailers and distributors in an effort to be their sole supplier, with this revolver likely an example of that. The barrel has the one-line Hartford address on top. The left side of the frame has the two-line patent dates marking. The left side of the trigger guard is stamped with the caliber designation: "45 CAL." The ejector rod has a bull's eye head. Matching full or partial serial numbers appear on the frame, trigger guard, back strap, barrel, and cylinder. The loading gate has the assembly number "1629."
Class: Antique
Fine, retaining 60% period Colt retailer applied nickel plating with a smooth gray patina on the balance. The slightly age shrunken grip is very fine with minor handling marks and highly attractive colors. Mechanically fine. The stock is excellent retaining 95% plus original nickel plating and some scratches. These attachable skeleton stocks are rarely encountered and are an essential accessory to any SAA collection. This antique Colt Single Action Army Revolver with rare attachable skeleton stock will be a prized addition to even the most advanced public or private collections.
Provenance: The TTT Collection
F.J. Haynes "Old Faithful" Print Hand Colored by L.A. Huffman
Lot # 3133 (Sale Order: 134 of 606)
"Old Faithful," is a hand colored print from Frank Jay Haynes (1853-1921), the noted official photographer of the Northern Pacific Railroad and Yellowstone National Park. It measures 16 1/2 inches by 21 1/2 and depicts one of the United States' most famous natural formations; Old Faithful. The lower right corner is embossed "PHOTO/YELLOWSTONE PARK". The geyser which is located in the Northwestern corner of Wyoming in Yellowstone National Park has become the most famous attraction in the park. This hand colorized print shows Old Faithful in all its glory of a full geyser, which on average launches boiling water 145 feet into the air.
Class: Other
Very fine with some corner wear, a distinct image, and vivid coloration. This would make an excellent addition to any Old West themed gun room or office!
Provenance: The John Fox Collection
First Generation Colt Single Action Army Revolver
Lot # 3134 (Sale Order: 135 of 606)
The Colt Single Action Army Revolver is arguably the most iconic American handgun. In the hands of ranchers, cavalrymen, Native Americans, lawmen, and outlaws, the Peacemaker’s legacy was forged out in the hostile American West and continues to gain popularity among today's collectors. Offered here is a very attractive, outstanding example of the legendary Peacemaker chambered in the iconic .45 LC caliber and fitted with relief carved steer head grips. It is easy to imagine this SAA carried at the hip of a flamboyant rancher down at the border. This revolver was manufactured in 1940, the last year of First Generation Colt Single Action Army revolver production. The barrel is marked with the two-line Hartford address on top and "COLT SINGLE ACTION ARMY 45" on the left side. The left side of the frame is marked with the two-line, three patent dates followed by the Rampant Colt. The upper left front of the trigger guard is marked with the Colt triangle "VP" proof mark and the number "4". The revolver wears a set of silver Rampant Colt medallion grips featuring a relief steer head carved on the right panel. Both grip panels are numbered to the gun. The assembly number “103” appears on the loading gate and rear of the frame. The matching serial number appears on the frame, trigger guard, back strap, and both grip panels. Blue finish with casehardened frame and blade front and frame notch rear sights. Complete with the original black hinged lid box numbered to the gun with end label reading "IVORY" over "RUBBER" for the grips and "Cvd Steers Hd Ivory" sticker on the top lid end flap, “Shooting Suggestions” pamphlet, and wire brush.
Class: Curio & Relic Handgun
Excellent. The revolver retains 97% plus original blue finish with some mild muzzle and high edge wear, a light drag line on the cylinder and some minor spotting on the grip straps. The frame retains 98% plus vivid original bright case colors. The grips are also excellent with a very attractive grain, only light handling marks overall, and relief craving. The markings are sharp. The action is excellent. The box is fine with a separated corner on the lid flap, a tear on the front lid flap and some edge and corner wear. An impressive carved stock pre-World War II Colt Single Action Army Revolver that will be a welcomed addition to any SAA collection.
Provenance: The Gateway Collection; Property of a Gentleman
Colt Flattop Target Model Single Action Army Revolver
Lot # 3135 (Sale Order: 136 of 606)
Manufactured in 1893. It is one of approximately only 925 Flattop Target Model Single Action Army revolvers produced. Only 122 of these rare and desirable standard frame, flattop revolvers were chambered in .38 Colt (see David Brown's "The 36 Calibers of the Colt Single Action Army," page 170). The revolver has the distinctive flat top strap with dovetail mounted target rear sight and block mounted front sight with adjustable blade. The top of the barrel is marked with the standard one-line Hartford address and "38 COLT." on the left. The left of the frame has the standard two-line patent marking followed by the circled Rampant Colt. London proofs appear on the underside of the barrel and alternate at the rear of the cylinder between the chambers. Matching serial numbers are visible on the bottom of the frame, trigger guard, and back strap, with "15" assembly number marked inside the loading gate. It is fitted with a pair of checkered hard rubber grips with Rampant Colts at the tops and Federal Eagle at the bottoms. The partitioned case carries the Colt Pall Mall London paper label on the interior of the lid and a blank brass circular inscription plaque on the exterior of the lid. The case is line in red felt and contains a glass oiler and two cleaning rods.
Class: Antique
Fine, retaining 50% original blue finish with a smooth brown patina on the balance and touch up around the front sight. The grips are very fine with a few minor handling marks and softened checkering. Mechanically excellent. The case is fine with some stress cracks at the screws and a complete Colt London label.
Provenance: The Gateway Collection
Cased Colt SA Flattop London Target Model Revolver in 450 Eley
Lot # 3136 (Sale Order: 137 of 606)
Manufactured in 1890. The Colt Single Action Army Flattop revolver is one of the most highly sought after models of Colt revolver by collectors. Colt only produced 925 and of those only made 84 in the 450 Eley caliber making the Flattop Target Model very rare. Adding to the rarity of this revolver is the fact that only a few had the London address on the barrel. The top of the barrel is marked "COLT' S PT. F.A. MFG. CO. HARTFORD CT. U.S.A. DEPOT 14 PALL MALL LONDON". The left side is marked " 450 ELEY." and the three-line, three patent dates are marked on the left side of the frame. There is no Rampant Colt present. British proofs are present on the underside of the barrel ahead of the cylinder pin, and similar markings are on the cylinder flutes. The revolver is fitted with checkered hard rubber Rampant Colt/American Eagle relief grips. The revolver is all blue finished. All serial numbers match. The accompanying factory letter dated February 3, 1960, states that the page with the information listing the shipment of 24 Single Action Army Target Models to the Colt London Agency on about April 17, 1890 has the end torn off so that some of the serial number is absent; however, one of the 24 shipped had the serial number "1327_ _" having the last two numbers torn away. The 24 shipped were listed as having a 7 1/2 inch barrel, rubber stocks and blue finish. Although it cannot be verified, the letter states that they feel certain that serial number 132700 was one of the 24 shipped that day. The revolver is complete in a very nice oak case with brass disk on the lid and red felt lining, with a label affixed to the inside of the lid that read, "Colts Patent Fire Arms Manufacturing Co/ 14 Pall Mall. S.W./ London. The case has three compartments and a 33 round bullet block, (with bullets). Also in the case is a James Dixon oiler.
Class: Antique
Extremely fine overall. The revolver retains 70% bright original high polish blue finish with scattered areas of flaking, a mix of original blue finish and smooth plum patina, several scratches on the underside of the barrel and some areas of very fine pitting. The grips are excellent. The left panel has faded to brown, and they show minimal wear with very crisp checkering. The markings remain crisp and clear. Mechanically excellent. The case is very fine with some minor scratches on the exterior with fine original label.
Provenance: The Gateway Collection
Colt Single Action Army Revolver with Silver Inlaid Grip
Lot # 3137 (Sale Order: 138 of 606)
The included factory letter identify this revolver in .45 caliber with a 5 1/2 inch barrel, blue finish, and wood grip and indicate it was one of two shipped to Schoverling, Daly & Gales in New York City on December 13, 1911. The counterpart to this revolver, number 320916, was formerly in the Robert Q. Sutherland collection. It is pictured and described on page 254 of "The Book of Colt Firearms" by R.L. Wilson where the two revolvers are noted as cased by craftsman Lewis Woyce and fitted with silver inlaid grips by John Boss Jr., both of Philadelphia, for presentation in 1956 by Raymond L.J. Riling (1896-1974) to his identical twin sons: Joseph Raymond and Raymond Joseph Riling. The elder Riling was a Philadelphia architect and builder and became an important arms book collector, dealer, author, and publisher. A widely published newspaper article in 1940 noted Riling as already having a collection of 500 pistols and revolvers and many historic western arms such as a revolver owned by Billy the Kid, a gold inlaid and engraved Winchester identified as made for Wild Bill Hickok for him to give to Calamity Jane, and a revolver carried by Frank James. Many influential firearms collecting books were published by Ray Riling Arms Books Co. in the 20th century and into the 21st century. Among his own works were "Guns and Shooting: A Bibliography" and "The Powder Flask Book." Joseph Riling (1924-2009), also known as Captain Joe, took over his father 's business and authored "Art and Science of War in America: Bibliography of American Military Imprints 1690-1800" and "Baron von Steuben and His Regulations." When he died in 2009, his obituary noted he was a "nationally recognized authority on military arms, a member of the National Rifle Association and a dealer in books on military weapons..." and also indicated he served in the U.S. Navy during World War II on LST 854 (Kane County) in the Pacific. His twin brother served in the U.S. Army during the war.The revolver has a 5 1/2 inch barrel and is chambered for the .45 Colt cartridge. It has the high-polish Colt pre-WWI commercial blue finish, and the hammer and frame have vivid case colors. The barrel has the standard one-line Hartford address on the top and the caliber designation "45 COLT" on the left side. The left side of the frame has the Colt "two-line/three-date" patent marking followed by the encircled Rampant Colt trademark. The Colt "V/P" proof mark is stamped on the left front of the trigger guard, and an inspector's initial "W" is stamped on the rear. The serial number is located on the frame, trigger guard, and back strap. All of the serial numbers match. The walnut grips are inlaid with a detailed silver eagle on both sides. The left side of the grip is inlaid with a silver oval engraved with the initials "JR" at the top. The right side of the grip has a silver, five-pointed star inlaid in the same position. The 12 inch by 7 inch mahogany case has the cover inlaid with a detailed spread eagle and shield with ribbon in an oval. The inlay is executed in contrasting wood, and the shield is colored red, white and blue. The case is lined with blue velvet and divided into six compartments. One compartment has a silver overlaid wood lid, and another is fitted with a silver block for twenty-five cartridges. The case contains a silver oil bottle and cleaning rod with brush, two brass tips, and a screwdriver.
Class: Curio & Relic Handgun
Excellent plus overall. The revolver has 98% plus of the bright original high polish Colt blue finish. Wear is limited to some very minor handling marks on the trigger guard and some light drag marks on the cylinder. The case colors on the frame and hammer are brilliant. Virtually all the original casehardened finish is present. The revolver appears to be unfired. The expertly crafted silver inlaid grip is in exceptionally fine condition. The case is very fine overall. The decorated lid has nearly all the original finish with minor scratches. The front of the case has a few storage and handling scratches near the lock. The case interior is fine with fading, oil staining, and cartridge head impressions on lining. This is a very impressive cased Single Action Army revolver presented by an influential collector and publisher to his son who carried on his legacy.
Provenance: The Riling Family Collection; Property of a Gentleman
R.A.C. Sub-Inspected U.S. Colt Cavalry Model SAA Revolver
Lot # 3138 (Sale Order: 139 of 606)
This Colt Single Action Cavalry Model revolver was manufactured in 1890 under the 12th Ordnance contract. 1890 was the next-to-last year of production for U.S. contract Single Action revolvers. The revolver was inspected by Ordnance Sub-Inspector Rinaldo A. Carr (R.A.C.) and Captain Stanhope E. Blunt (SEB). It has the Colt military blue finish on the barrel, ejector housing, cylinder, trigger guard and back strap. The frame, loading gate and hammer have a color casehardened finish and the one-piece walnut grip is oil finished. The revolver has the oval ejector housing adopted about serial number 113,000 and the "cavalry style" hammer with elongated, bordered, knurling on the spur. The top of the barrel is roll-stamped with address "COLT'S PT. F.A. MFG. Co. HARTFORD CT. U.S.A.-" in elongated block letters. The left side of the frame is roll-stamped with the Colt three-date/three-line patent markings followed by the "U.S" property mark. The Sub-Inspector's initials, "R.A.C." are stamped on the underside of the barrel, the bottom of the frame above the serial number, on the side of the cylinder and on the left heel of the grip. A "K" Colt sub-inspection mark is stamped on the trigger guard, the back strap, on the front of the ejector housing and on the barrel behind the ejector housing stud, with "P" proof marks stamped on the underside of the barrel, in front of the "R.A.C." sub-inspection mark and on the side of the cylinder. The full serial number is stamped on the bottom of the frame, trigger guard and back strap. The partial serial number "2215", is stamped on the barrel beneath the ejector housing and on the side of the cylinder. All of the visible serial numbers match. The assembly number, "848", is stamped on the inside of the loading gate. The lower left side of the grip is stamped with the date "1890" above the script initials "SEB" enclosed in a rectangle with rounded edges. The script sub-inspection mark, which consists of the script initials "RAC" in a rectangle is stamped on the lower right side of the grip. With a John A. Kopec letter dated March 1st, 1999 stating it was a new listing and that it was probably issued to the 8th Cavalry. There are a few minor deviations from originality, the trigger is a replacement, the mainspring has been ground for a better trigger pull and the grip strap has been drilled for a grip pin.
Class: Antique
Exceptionally fine. The revolver retains 80% plus of the original blue and color casehardened finish. The "feathered" polishing marks are visible on either side of the front sight blade. The left side of the barrel and right side of the ejector housing have some light holster wear. The cylinder has some holster wear on high points and light drag lines. The trigger guard has most of the blue with some thinning on the grip strap. The back strap has typical handling wear and the blue has thinned to a gray patina. The case colors on the loading gate have faded to a silver-gray patina. The frame and grip screws retain most of the niter blue finish. The grip is very fine with very minor handling wear and strong date, final inspection and sub-inspection marks. The action is tight and crisp but the hammer will not hold at half-cock. This is an exceptional original example of an 1890 production, "R.A.C." sub-inspection Colt Single Action Cavalry Model revolver.
Provenance: The Gateway Collection
Antique Colt Single Action Army Revolver
Lot # 3139 (Sale Order: 140 of 606)
The Colt Single Action Army was one of the most popular handguns in late 19th century and is easily the most iconic and most thoroughly associated with the American West. Offered here is an early example of the legendary Peacemaker in .45 LC. In the words of Colt author and expert David Brown, "The Colt Single Action Army .45 was 'the soldier's friend' throughout the remaining years of the Indian Wars in the West. Adopted also with equal enthusiasm by civilians, it was the pet and the 'good right arm' of lawman and outlaw alike on every American frontier of its era" ("The 36 Calibers of the Colt Single Action Army," p. 70). The accompanying factory letter states the revolver was shipped to Simmons Hardware Co. of St. Louis, Missouri, on September 10, 1886, with a 7 1/2 inch barrel in .45 caliber, desirable nickel finish, and pearl stocks. This was a five gun shipment. The barrel has the one-line Hartford address on top. The left side of the frame has the three-line patent dates marking. The left side of the trigger guard is stamped "45 CAL." Matching serial numbers appear on the frame, trigger guard, and back strap.
Class: Antique
Fine, retaining 60% original nickel plating with a smooth gray patina on the balance. The grips are very fine with slight chipping along the inside edges, a few typical age lines, and filled tiny chips at the heels. Mechanically excellent. A solid original black powder Colt SAA with desirable factory nickel finish and pearl stocks.
Colt Bisley Model Single Action Army Revolver
Lot # 3140 (Sale Order: 141 of 606)
The Colt Bisley model was only manufactured in 1894-1912 and was designed by Colt with accuracy and target shooting in mind. For many, the Bisley feels better in the hand and cocks and fires easier thanks to its lower and wider hammer and the wider trigger, making them excellent sidearms for serious marksmen. This example of Colt's famed Bisley in desirable .45 LC was manufactured in 1900. Accompanying the revolver is an extra factory cylinder chambered in .45 ACP purchased during World War II by a USAAF officer. As documented by the included October 14, 1943, Colt order letter (copy), the .45 ACP cylinder was purchased at a cost of $6.00 by Lt. Harry Rubin of the U.S. Army Forces Equipment Board, Army Air Forces School of Applied Tactics, Orlando, Florida. The .45 ACP round was used by the U.S. Military during World War II for the Model 1911 and 1911A1 semi-automatic pistols. This chambering was first made available after World War I in 1924 on a special order basis to the SAA production line. Colt historian and author David Brown stated, "Almost all made after 1924 were shipped to men in some branch of the Armed Forces. They could get all of the .45 Auto ammo they wanted but part of them wanted to shoot the Colt Single Action Army instead of Colt Automatic so they would order the Colt SAA made up in the .45 ACP" ("The 36 Calibers of the Colt Single Action Army," page 62). As a .45 caliber Bisley owned by a WWII officer, it made perfect sense for Lt. Rubin to purchase a cylinder chambered in .45 ACP, a standard U.S. military caliber readily available to him. The Army Air Forces Tactical Center was established in 1942 and trained combat units in tactical air power doctrine. Matching serial numbers appear on the frame, trigger guard, and back strap. The barrel has the one-line Hartford address on top and "(BISLEY MODEL) 45 COLT" on the left side. The left side of the frame has the two-line patent dates marking followed by an encircled Rampant Colt logo. Wide, low hammer spur with wide trigger and characteristic "humpback" grip. Fitted with checkered hard rubber grips with Rampant Colt logo at the top.
Class: Curio & Relic Handgun
Fine as a revolver that spent time in a subtropical climate during World War II in the hands of a USAAF officer. The barrel, cylinder, and ejector rod housing retain 60% original blue finish, and the grip straps retain 20% original blue finish. The frame and hammer retain 40% original case colors. There is some scattered pitting. The grips are excellent with a few handling marks and overall crisp checkering. Mechanically excellent. The .45 ACP cylinder is excellent with 98% original blue. A Colt Bisley revolver with a World War II connection.
Provenance: USAAF Lt. Harry Rubin; Property of a Gentleman
L. Kiper & Sons, Atchison, Kansas "Mexican Loop" Holster Rig
Lot # 3141 (Sale Order: 142 of 606)
Manufactured in the mid-1870s to 1890s by L. Kiper & Sons of Atchison, Kansas. By the late 1860s and early 1870s, with the arrival of multiple railroad links, Atchison had become a booming commercial hub, particularly for the cattle industry and manufactured goods heading farther west to the Frontier. Period newspapers show L. Kiper & Sons advertising their leather business there starting in the early 1870s and continuing until at least the 1890s. This is a fine example of a "Mexican Loop" type holster that was popular during the period that has two oval loops capturing the body of the holster, with the top one bearing the maker's mark. There is light border and floral tooling on the body of the holster. A very similar example of a Kiper & Sons holster is pictured on p. 106 of "Packing Iron: Gunleather of the Frontier West" by Rattenbury. Included with the holster is an early style cartridge belt that is certainly of Kiper quality and appears to have been paired with the holster for quite some time judging by consistent color and wear. It has a single row of cartridge loops that are of .44 or .45 caliber size and has a "California style" buckle with clipped corners. The belt is 2 1/8 inches wide and measures approximately 40 3/8 inches long including the buckle and billet.
Class: Other
Good, the holster showing significant wear, typical of working gunleather from the Kansas cattle era, some scattered mild age cracking, and most of the tooling and markings remaining clear. The belt shows similar wear, having the look of being a companion of the holster for some time with some moderate age-related cracking. A rare piece of Kansas-made gunleather from the period of westward expansion!
Engraved Colt Black Powder Single Action Army Revolver
Lot # 3142 (Sale Order: 143 of 606)
The Colt Single Action Army Revolver is one of the most iconic historical firearms and is forever connected to the American West. Its legacy as a working man's gun in rough circumstances has made the Peacemaker particularly desirable for collectors, and the limited factory engraved guns especially so. This SAA no. 30256 is especially appealing as the embellishment is highly unusual and rare. Unfortunately, there is no factory record available for this SAA; however, serial no. 30259, which is only two digits away from our subject revolver, is fully documented as Colt factory engraved and the embellishment is nearly identical to what is featured on this revolver. No. 30259 is pictured and identified in R.L. Wilson’s “Colt Engraving” on page 247. Wilson described the engraving as “handsome and unusual” with “quite light and graceful” scrollwork and while not profuse, the pattern of engraving includes “the quite scarce coverage on the hammer.” No. 30259 letters as shipped in January 1880 to Simmons Hardware of St. Louis and this shipment included five guns. It is quite possible that our revolver was also part of the January 1880 shipment. Based on the serial numbers, both of these revolvers were manufactured in 1876. The four year delay from when no. 30259 was manufactured and shipped suggests the revolver was a Colt factory exhibition piece. Add the “handsome and unusual embellishments” and no. 30256 makes for the perfect exhibition companion. The year 1876 was the same year the World's Fair was held in the United States for the first time in celebration of the centennial of the Declaration of Independence and the founding of the United States. Fittingly, the Centennial Exposition was held in Philadelphia. The fair presented a tremendous advertising opportunity for American arms companies like Colt and Winchester. Both displayed elaborate exhibition arms and took in orders, including for high end deluxe arms. Colt's famous display was perhaps the factory’s most spectacular display in its history. While there is no documentation to confirm one or both of these revolvers were at the Centennial Exposition, nos. 30256 and 30259 would have without a doubt made for a fine pair for Colt to proudly display. The barrel has the one-line Hartford address surrounded by the engraving, a light wavy line band at the muzzle, and an entwining oval pattern with punch dot around the front sight. The frame has the two-line patent date on the left side as well as the broad floral scrollwork. The cylinder is decorated with scrolls on each chamber, star bursts at each flute and light scroll band at the rear. The scrollwork carries on the back strap, ejector rod housing, hammer, and trigger guard. A fan pattern is engraved on the top of the back strap. The revolver wears a set of pearl grips and each panel is numbered to the gun on the back. Traces of the serial number remains on the barrel under the ejector housing and appears to be matching. Matching full or partial serial numbers appear on the frame, trigger guard, back strap, and cylinder. Includes an unmarked tooled leather open top/closed toe holster featuring an elaborate horse rider scene.
Class: Antique
Fine, retaining 80% period replated nickel finish with a smooth brown patina on the balance. The engraving is crisp. A tiny hole has been drilled through the side of the front sight. The grips are very good with a few missing chips and attractive fiery colors. Mechanically excellent. The holster is very good with strap partially attached. This black powder Colt SAA revolver with "handsome and unusual embellishments" is a rarity in decorative firearms art and is a must have for the serious SAA collector.
Nickel U.S. Cavalry Model Colt Single Action Army Revolver
Lot # 3143 (Sale Order: 144 of 606)
This example has a David F. Clark inspected "U.S." marked frame and a full nickel finish. Nickel plated Cavalry Models have taken center stage to a grand debate among Colt and U.S. military firearms collectors that continues on to today. Four basic theories for the existence of highly controversial nickel plated U.S. Cavalry Model Revolvers have developed over the decades and are the following: 1) issued to Indian Scouts and Police; 2) special order "officers" revolvers; 3) surplus State of Virginia Militia revolvers sold to and nickel plated by Colt or commercial retailers; and 4) U.S. Navy revolvers. For the history related to this ongoing debate see "A Study of Colt Single Action Army Revolver" pages 249-258. Clark's "DFC" initials appear on the barrel, frame, and cylinder. The "P" proof appears on the cylinder and barrel. The top of the barrel is marked with the one-line Colt address, and the left of the frame has the three-line patent markings followed by "U.S." The butt is inscribed with a large "C" in Old English font. The loading gate is stamped with the assembly number "337". Full and partial matching visible serial numbers located on the frame, trigger guard, back strap, barrel, and cylinder.
Class: Antique
Very fine, retaining 80% untouched period retailer refinished nickel with high spot wear and some flaking. A back strap screw is absent. The undersized period grip is fine with typical age lines on the bottom and minor handling marks. Mechanically functions although needs work as it is missing the half cock notch.
Modern Battery Gun Co. 1862 Gatling Gun with Carriage and Tripod
Lot # 3144 (Sale Order: 145 of 606)
Manufactured by the Battery Gun Co. of Metamora, Michigan, as a full scale, fully functional Gatling gun. The construction of the main body is brass, with the Battery Gun data plate on top, an array of blued barrels with blued support arms. Intended for use with the included .45 Long Colt caliber steel chamber inserts. The included carriage is of steel and hardwood construction, with an elevation adjustment screw, and the included tripod is also of steel and hardwood construction. Also includes four extra magazines.
Class: Modern Other Firearm
Excellent, retains 99% original blue finish on the barrels, and the brass is bright with a few areas of slight dulling. Mechanically excellent. Carriage is excellent, with 99% painted finish and some light corrosion on outer wheel bands and aiming bar. Tripod is also excellent with a few light handling marks.
Desirable Furr Miniature Model 1874 Gatling Gun with Case
Lot # 3145 (Sale Order: 146 of 606)
This is a quality made scaled down functional copy of the Colt-Gatling Model 1874 in .22 LR. Brass construction with wooden wheels. The top of the body is fitted with a miniature Colt Gatling gun plaque. Includes a scaled down Broadwell type magazine. The major components and most of the small parts are stamped with the serial number "25". Includes a hardwood carriage with brass fittings and yoke, transom and elevation adjustment, and a display case. Carriage measures 18 inches high at the wheels, 22 inches wide across the axle, and approximately 27 inches long from the axle to the rear.
Class: Modern Other Firearm
Excellent overall, with some light display and handling marks, some discoloration around patent plate (see image), and some light surface oxidation on the barrels. Mechanically excellent.
Factory Engraved Colt Model 1851 Percussion Revolver
Lot # 3146 (Sale Order: 147 of 606)
This gorgeous Colt Model 1851 Navy revolver was manufactured in 1852 in the early years of Colt employing German trained engravers and displays the distinctive foliate scroll engraving inhabited by masks on the left side of the barrel and frame, beaded backgrounds, and a bestial motif on the hammer rather than the soon to be standard wolf head. The "COLTS/PATENT" marking on the frame is also hand inscribed in a panel rather than stamped. The barrel features a cone front sight and the one-line "-ADDRESS SAML COLT NEW YORK CITY-" marking. A "4" is marked among the rayed ornamentation on the left side of the barrel lug and on the cylinder below the serial number. The left side of the trigger guard has a "C" and "G". The factory dot marking designating factory engraving is marked by the matching serial numbers on the barrel, frame, trigger guard, and back strap. Matching serial numbers are visible on the loading lever and cylinder. The wedge is non-matching.
Class: Antique
Very fine with crisp engraving and markings, 75% plus original silver plating with aged patina on the grip straps, smooth smoky gray patina on the casehardened components, 70% plus refinished blue on the cylinder, 60% original blue on the barrel, smooth gray and brown patina on the balance, and fairly minimal wear. The grip is very fine and has glossy piano varnish, light scratches and dings, and some hammering marks on the butt. Mechanically excellent.
Provenance: Property of a Distinguished Southern Clergyman
Colt Paterson Second Model Ring Lever Percussion Rifle
Lot # 3147 (Sale Order: 148 of 606)
Samuel Colt manufactured approximately 500 Second Model Ring Lever Rifles at his Paterson, New Jersey, factory in 1838-1841. These rifles were serial numbered in their own range starting with serial number 1. Surviving examples of this historically significant Colt firearm are extremely rare. This rifle is featured on pages 188 and 189 of "The Paterson Colt Book" by R.L. Wilson and is discussed extensively on pages 199-201. Robert Pershing later in that section notes that "It is my belief, after subsequent research, that this rifle might well have been one of the second shipment, October 8, 1839. The rifle was issued to a soldier in the Texas Army and was kept by him when discharged. He started a cattle operation in South Eastern Texas, utilizing Galveston as a port for shipping his livestock. Later, he and his kin moved to Louisiana taking the gun with them. The family operated this ranch until the late 1920's or early 1930's. Paul Sorrell, a collector-dealer in Beaumont, Texas, discovered the rifle in the hands of the great-grandson of the original owner, who indeed could remember his grandmother telling about great grandfather using the rifle to kill cattle on their range on Grand Isle, Louisiana. The great-grandson was a druggist in Houma, Louisiana. This rifle came out of the brush, passed down, from generation to generation until 1991...The serial number is in the range that was sold...to the Government of Texas..." The great-grandson is identified as David Norman of Houma, Louisiana, and it is stated that the rifle had been in his family since 1840. Further investigation reveals that he was born in 1935 and his father was David J. Norman Sr. (1905-1972), also a pharmacist in Houma, Louisiana, and his mother was Isabelle Carey Norman (1906-1995). It is not clear which of their ancestors was identified as the original owner, but from genealogical records it would appear his great-grandfathers all were too young to have been soldiers in 1840. One of his great-great grandfathers, Jose "Pepe" Llulla (1815-1888), was a noted duelist and fencing master in New Orleans and owned land on Grand Terre Island in Barataria Bay and raised livestock there, so it may have been him that the grandmother was referring to.The rifle has the distinctive ring on the bottom of the frame ahead of the trigger guard to rotate the cylinder and cock the internal hammer and the Second Model type frame without a top strap. Other Second Model features include the loading lever, capping cutout in the recoil shield, and rounded shoulders of the cylinder. The barrel has the dovetail mounted blade front sight and dovetail mounted elevation adjustable notch rear sight. The top barrel flat is stamped "~*Patent Arms M'g. Co. Paterson, N.J.-Colt's Pt.*~" reading towards the muzzle. The cylinder has the centaur, hunter, and deer scene. The matching serial number is stamped on the face of the barrel lug, rear cylinder face, and cylinder collar as well as a partial "82" at the toe of the crescent iron buttplate. The book states matching serial numbers also appear on several other components in concealed areas. The stock has a cheekpiece.
Class: Antique
Very good plus with distinct markings and cylinder scene, mottled gray and brown patina, some minor oxidation, and general mild wear. The stock is fine and has some scratches and dings, crack/reglued chip visible at the heel, and some deeper scrapes. Mechanically fine.
Colt 1861 Navy Richards-Mason Conversion Revolver with Holster
Lot # 3148 (Sale Order: 149 of 606)
Manufactured in 1864 and subsequently factory converted to centerfire in the mid-1870s. The top of the barrel is roll-stamped with a faint New York address visible underneath the finish, with "-PAT. JULY.25. 1871-/-PAT.JULY. 2. 1872.-" two-line patent markings on the left of the frame, the cylinder is engraved with the Texas naval battle scene, the left of the trigger guard is stamped with "36 CAL", the cylinder is stamped "COLTS PATENT No.096". All matching visible serial numbers on the wedge, cylinder, cylinder pin, loading gate, barrel, frame, trigger guard and back strap. The revolver has the distinctive plug in the loading lever hole of the barrel lug, ejector head with concentric rings, ejector housing screw on the left side of the barrel lug and loading gate spring screwed to the frame above the trigger screw. Includes a period tooled leather holster with floral designs.
Class: Antique
Fine, retains 70% plus factory refurbished blue finish with scattered flaking and smooth gray and brown patina on the balance characteristic of a western used gun, strong case colors showing at the edges and in protected areas, and golden aged patina on the brass. Absent tip of the wedge retaining spring. Grip is also fine with scattered light dents and scratches, and defined edges. Mechanically excellent. Holster is very fine with a few light handling marks. This fine Colt 1861 Navy Richards-Mason conversion revolver with its tooled holster would fit well in any western firearms collection!
Colt Model 1861 Navy Percussion Revolver
Lot # 3149 (Sale Order: 150 of 606)
This revolver was manufactured in 1861 and is one of only an estimated 38,843 manufactured between 1861-1873, compared to 200,500 Model 1860 Army revolvers manufactured between 1860-1873. It has a German silver blade front sight, the one-line New York address, "COLTS/PATENT" on the left side of the frame, "36 CAL" on the left side of the trigger guard, and a smooth one-piece walnut grip. Matching serial numbers are found on the barrel, frame, trigger guard, back strap, cylinder, wedge, and arbor pin.
Class: Antique
Very good, displaying an overall gray patina of a well-traveled sidearm that has seen a lifetime of service with 30% original soft military style blue finish remaining on the barrel, 30% original case colors in the protected areas, and much of the cylinder scene remaining. The grip is good showing authentic "working gun" wear and tear. Mechanically excellent. A Civil War era Colt Model 1861 Navy percussion revolver with great character.
Provenance: Property of a Distinguished Southern Clergyman