
Premier Firearms Auction - Day 3
Premier Firearms Auction - Day 3
See Special Terms for additional fees
Cash Payment Discount: 3.5%
Description
Special Ordered Casehardened Winchester Deluxe Model 1873 Rifle
Lot # 3000 (Sale Order: 1 of 616)
Manufactured in 1884, this is a fine representative example of an antique, special ordered, Winchester deluxe Model 1873 rifle. The included factory letter lists the rifle in "Model 1873" caliber (meaning .44-40 W.C.F.) with an octagon barrel, plain trigger, checkered pistol grip stock, and casehardened finish when received at the warehouse on 6 September 1884 and shipped on 8 September 1884 in order number 14983. According to noted Winchester historian and author George Madis, approximately one in every 600 Model 1873s was ordered with special wood and one in every 700 had checkering. Madis does not list the rarity of casehardened finishes, but they are comparatively quite scarce. The top of the barrel is marked with the standard two-line address and King's patent marking, as well as the caliber marking at the breech. The caliber marking is repeated on the bottom of the cartridge elevator. The model marking is on the upper tang and the serial is marked on the lower tang. The left side of the lower tang is marked "5408 XXX R", with "5408" repeated in the stock inlet and inside the buttplate. Additionally, the butt of the stock is marked "2586", the meaning of which is unknown. It is fitted with a gold washed combination front sight, elevation adjustable buckhorn rear sight, and there is a rare Winchester 62-B peep sight mounted on the upper tang including the stud for the sight to engage with when in the down position. It is mounted with a very finely figured, H-pattern checkered forearm and pistol grip stock with a hard rubber grip cap and a trapdoor crescent buttplate containing an included four-piece cleaning rod. Also included are two pins.
Class: Antique
Fine, retains 60% of the original blue finish and 70% of the vibrant original case colors with the balance mostly a grey patina, a few scattered spots of light pitting, numerous patches of mild pitting/oxidation on the left below the ejection port and right of barrel, and scattered patches of brown freckling. The buttstock is very fine while the otherwise fine forearm is damaged with a large chip/gouge absent from the top right side of the forearm, some scattered minor handling marks, and mostly crisp checkering. Mechanically excellent.
Special Order Winchester Model 1894 Lever Action Takedown Rifle
Lot # 3001 (Sale Order: 2 of 616)
Manufactured in 1903, this is an outstanding example of a special ordered Winchester Model 1894 takedown rifle in a very attractive configuration. The included factory letter lists the rifle in .32 W.S. caliber with a half octagon barrel, plain trigger, Lyman combination front sight, half magazine, shotgun butt, and in takedown configuration when received at the warehouse on 19 June 1903 and shipped on 23 June 1903 in order number 188925. The top barrel flat is marked with the two-line address and the caliber marking at the breech, while the upper left flat has the nickel steel marking. The three-line model, trademark, and patent marking is on the upper tang, and the serial number is marked on the bottom of the receiver. It has a special order half octagon barrel, half magazine, and a smooth steel shotgun buttplate. It is fitted with a combination front sight and the special "SMOKELESS/-.32W.S.-M.'94-" marked elevation adjustable rear sight. It is mounted with a nicely figured smooth forearm and straight grip stock with a smooth shotgun buttplate.
Class: Curio & Relic Long Gun
Excellent, retains 90% plus of the original blue finish, 75% of the vibrant case colors on the hammer and lever, and 80% plus of the original nitre blue on the loading gate with the balance mostly a smooth grey patina, most noticeably on top of the receiver ring and the buttplate, and a few very light spots of pitting where the takedown collar meets the receiver. The wood is also excellent with a few scattered minor handling marks. Mechanically excellent.
Factory Smoothbore Marked Winchester Model 1892 Carbine
Lot # 3002 (Sale Order: 3 of 616)
Manufactured in 1912, this is a very scarce example of a Winchester Model 1892 saddle ring carbine with a factory smoothbore barrel. This particular example also has a nickel finished frame and buttplate, as well as nickel finished plaques inlaid in either side of the stock featuring the Winchester trademark showing traces of red enamel that once filled it. Smoothbore rifles, revolvers, and carbines like this one were popular in the late 1800s and early 1900s among exhibition shooters, particularly for trap style shooting of glass target balls, clays, and other airborne items. This example with the large Winchester trademark plaques and the nickel finish was almost certainly made by Winchester for one of their exhibition shooters for use at company advertising demonstrations. The upper left of the barrel is marked with the two-line address and patent date. The left of the barrel at the breech is marked "SMOOTH BORE - 44 W.C.F." The bore correctly measures at .43 caliber as the barrels were pulled off the line before rifling grooves were cut. The upper tang is marked with the three-line model and trademark information, and the bottom of the receiver is marked with the serial number. It is fitted with a pinned blade front sight, a folding ladder rear sight, and a saddle ring on the left of the receiver. It is mounted with a smooth forearm and straight grip stock with a carbine buttplate. Included with the carbine is a very rare target ball mold made of brass and embossed with a conjoined "JE" on both sides. This mold would have been used to make target balls of the type this carbine would have been used to shoot in exhibitions. Also included is a modern suede pouch.
Class: Curio & Relic Long Gun
Fine, retains 30% of the original blue finish on sheltered areas of the barrel and magazine tube and 85% plus of the original nickel finish on the remaining components, including the trademark plaques. Faint traces of red enamel remain in the Winchester markings on the plaques. The wood is very good with minor handling marks scattered throughout, typical of a well-used exhibition gun. Mechanically fine. The target ball mold is fine with attractively aged patina overall. A rare configuration Model 1892 carbine that was likely used by a Winchester exhibition shooter!
Factory Ballistic Lab Shipped Winchester Model 1886 Rifle
Lot # 3003 (Sale Order: 4 of 616)
Manufactured in 1914, this very interesting Winchester Model 1886 is documented as shipped to the factory Ballistic Lab in the New Tools and Cartridge Department. The included factory letter lists the rifle in .33 W.C.F. caliber with a round barrel, full magazine, rubber shotgun butt, and takedown when received at the warehouse on 7 June 1916 and shipped the same day in order number 782405 to "Ballistic Lab, New Tools and Cartridge Department". The rifle has the standard factory oval proofs on top of the barrel and receiver (double struck, factory error) at the breech. The barrel has the "lightweight" tapered profile which was standard in the .33 W.C.F. caliber and is marked on the left with the two-line address/patent dates, nickel steel marking, and caliber marking. The upper tang is marked with the three-line model and trademark information, while the serial number is marked on the lower tang. The left sides of the upper and lower tangs are both marked with two punch dots, possibly markings related to the factory stock replacement. It is fitted with a ramped Patridge blade front sight and an elevation adjustable notch rear sight, and the rifle is in takedown configuration. It is mounted with a smooth forearm and straight grip stock with a steel crescent buttplate, with the buttstock and crescent steel buttplate being factory repaired replacements.
Class: Curio & Relic Long Gun
Very fine, retaining 90% plus of the blue finish with some scattered light handling marks and specks of flaking. The replacement buttstock is also very fine with factory repairs on either side of the upper tang and a few scattered light handling marks. Mechanically excellent. A unique Model 1886 rifle documented as shipped with the Winchester Ballistic Lab!
Winchester Model 1894 Lever Action Saddle Ring Carbine
Lot # 3004 (Sale Order: 5 of 616)
Manufactured in 1915, this is an incredibly high condition, outstanding example of Winchester's prolific Model 1894 saddle ring carbine. It is almost difficult to believe that this carbine in such outstanding condition is 110 years old! These carbines were primarily viewed as working guns in the American West, well into the 20th century, and were valued for their compact firepower. Due to being viewed as simply a tool by many who carried them, it is extremely rare to find an example in near flawless condition like this one. The top of the barrel and receiver have Winchester factory oval proofs at the breech. The barrel has the two-line address and patent dates on the upper left and the nickel steel and caliber markings are on the left. The upper tang is has the three-line model and trademark information, and the serial number is marked on the bottom of the receiver. It is fitted with a saddle ring on the left of the receiver, a pinned blade front sight, folding ladder rear sight, and the upper tang is factory drilled and tapped for a peep sight with a filler screw in place. It is mounted with a smooth forearm and straight grip stock with a carbine buttplate.
Class: Curio & Relic Long Gun
Excellent plus, near mint, retains 98% plus of the original blue finish with some light wear on the buttplate, a few small spots of brown visible on the bottom of the receiver, and a few scattered light handling marks. The wood is also excellent plus with a few scattered light dings and scratches. Mechanically excellent. It would be almost impossible to improve upon this example, if you are in search of a collection defining Winchester Model 1894 saddle ring carbine, look no further!
Antique Special Order Winchester Model 1892 Lever Action Rifle
Lot # 3005 (Sale Order: 6 of 616)
Manufactured in 1897, this is an exceptionally fine example of a special ordered Winchester Model 1892 rifle. These rifles and carbines, like the Model 1873 before, were highly prized in the American West due to being chambered in many of the same cartridges as Colt's Single Action Army revolver. These guns were often viewed as a "working gun", seeing hard use on the frontier, leaving very few early production examples in high condition like this one. The top of the barrel is marked with the two-line address and the caliber marking at the breech. The upper tang has the three-line model, trademark, and patent marking, and the serial number is marked on the bottom of the receiver. It is fitted with a set of "sporting sights" featuring a German silver blade front and elevation adjustable buckhorn rear, and it has a special ordered "button" magazine. It is mounted with a smooth forearm and straight grip stock with a crescent buttplate.
Class: Antique
Exceptionally fine, retains 85% of the original blue finish showing some thinning in a few areas and edges, 60% plus of the original case colors on the hammer and lever, 50% of the original nitre blue on the loading gate, and a few very small scattered patches of light pitting on the barrel where the blue has thinned slightly. The wood is very fine with some scattered minor handling marks. Mechanically excellent.
Winchester Model 1895 Lever Action Rifle
Lot # 3006 (Sale Order: 7 of 616)
Manufactured in 1921, with the Winchester factory oval proofs marked on the barrel and receiver at the breech. The left side of the barrel has the two-line nickel steel marking and the caliber marking. The left of the receiver is marked with the standard two-line address and patent dates. The upper tang is marked with the three-line model and trademark information, and the serial number is marked on the lower tang. It is fitted with a Lyman beaded blade front sight and a period replacement Savage Arms Corp. marked elevation adjustable notch rear sight. It is mounted with a smooth Schnabel tip forearm with an ebony insert and a straight grip stock with crescent buttplate.
Class: Curio & Relic Long Gun
Fine, with 70% of the original blue finish with numerous scattered patches of flaking on the receiver showing a grey patina and some light surface pitting. The wood is also fine with scattered light scratches and dings. Mechanically excellent.
Volcanic Repeating Arms Company No. 2 Navy Pistol
Lot # 3007 (Sale Order: 8 of 616)
This No. 2 Navy Pistol was manufactured by the Volcanic Repeating Arms Company circa 1856. The pistol has the distinctive octagon barrel with integral 10-shot magazine, brass receiver and loading lever with finger hole. The Type I barrel has a brass half-moon front sight blade and brass, clam-shell magazine follower. The top barrel flat is roll-stamped: "THE VOLCANIC/REPEATING ARMS CO./PATENT NEWHAVEN CONN. FEB. 14. 1854" in three lines. The brass receiver has semi-circular cut-outs at the front and back of the ejection port, a dove-tail mounted rear sight and hammer with coarse-knurled spur. The pistol has two-piece walnut grips with flared butts. The serial number is stamped: (1) on the right side of the loading lever, (2) right side of the butt beneath the grips and (3) on the inside of both grips. All of the visible serial numbers match. An "X" inspection mark is stamped on the left side of the loading lever. The barrel has a high polish blue finish, the receiver is natural brass, the hammer and lever are color casehardened, and the rear sight, bolt, trigger and cartridge elevator are fire blue. The walnut grips have a varnished piano finish. The Volcanic Repeating Arms Company manufactured approximately 1500 No. 2 Navy Pistols with eight-inch barrels before the company was forced to declare bankruptcy and was reorganized by Oliver Winchester as the New Haven Arms Company in 1857.
Class: Antique
Very fine. This pistol retains 85% of the original blue finish on the barrel and integral magazine. Finish wear is limited to some scattered age spotting and thinning along the bottom of the magazine shroud. The edges of the barrel flats are sharp and the barrel legend is crisp and deep. The attractive aged brass receiver is also very fine with perfect side plate joints, minimal handling marks and a very attractive, un-touched patina. The bolt, cartridge elevator, trigger and rear sight retain significant amounts to fire blue finish in protected areas. The hammer and loading lever have 70% of the casehardened finish. The grips are fine and have most of the original piano finish with scattered handling marks. Mechanically excellent. This is an exceptional example of a desirable Volcanic Repeating Arms Company No. 2 Navy Pistol.
Provenance: The Dr. Gerald Klaz Collection; Property of a Gentleman
Civil War Era New Haven Arms Company Henry Rifle
Lot # 3008 (Sale Order: 9 of 616)
Manufactured in March of 1864, this outstanding Civil War era production New Haven Arms Company Henry rifle is, without question, one of the finest known in existence. The Henry lever action rifle is among the most famous and desirable of all of the historic American lever action rifles as the predecessor to the famous Winchester lever action rifles, one of the most advanced firearms of the American Civil War, as well as a legendary icon of the American Frontier. Many of these advanced rifles were purchased by the federal government for use during the Civil War, and many more were also privately purchased by veterans using their reenlistment bonuses. Though they were more complex and fragile than the standard issue rifle-muskets of the day, soldiers of the day were eager to get their hands on the unprecedented rapid firepower the Henry brought to bear. Many of the Henrys that saw Civil War use, as well as many of those that didn't, later made their way farther west, playing a role in the taming of America's Frontier. In the wilds of the west, these rifles could be found in the hands of pioneers, Native Americans, outlaws, lawmen, and anyone else that valued the quick repeating shots the Henry had to offer. More often than not, these rifles saw hard use on the battlefield or the frontier and carry the wear and scars to prove it, leaving virtually none in the incredible condition that we find this example to be in. This specific rifle, serial number 4336, is certainly near the very pinnacle of Henry collecting, and would easily become of the crown jewel of even the most extensive lever action, frontier, or American firearms collections!This 1864 production Henry has the early style frame which shows an abrupt angle and only a slight edge bevel on the upper rear, which was standard until approximately the 4900 serial number range. The lever is of the second style with a spur that engages the lever latch screw, which entered production in the early 400 serial number range and continued until the end of production. The hammer has the correct course, hand-filed checkering. The frame correctly lacks a rear sight dovetail slot, a feature that was discontinued around the 3100 serial number range. The magazine follower is the correct, larger, second style and the frame has the correct milled flats in the receiver slot. The barrel has the correct, two-line, larger style Henry's patent and New Haven address marking, which appeared in the 3000 serial number range. The rear sight dovetail is just in front of the second style, larger-digit serial number, which is at the breech. The matching serial number is marked on the barrel, left side of the lower tang, in the stock inlet, inside the buttplate, and on the shank of both buttplate screws. The buttplate screws are hand-fitted to the contour of the buttplate and thus are correctly numbered, while the tang screws are not hand-fitted and correctly lack numbers, a transition variation which is seen in approximately the 3000-5600 serial number range. It is fitted the correct, square-backed, German silver blade front sight and correct folding ladder rear sight graduated to 900 yards. There are sling swivels mounted on the left of the barrel and left of the stock. It is correctly mounted with the last style buttstock, which entered production around the 3200 serial number range and has the gently sloping comb and flat bottom, as well as being fitted with the earlier style trapdoor buttplate with the rounded heel that was standard until around the 5100 serial number range.
Class: Antique
Excellent, retaining an incredible 90% plus of the original blue finish on the barrel/magazine tube, with some faint grey patina showing through in a few areas. The lever retains 60% of the original blue finish, with any original blue being almost unheard of on a Henry. 80% of the muted original case colors remain, most visible on the sides of the hammer. The bright brass shows an attractively aged patina, some faint darker patina in grooves and sheltered areas, and the edges remaining crisp and the sideplate junctions tight. The re-oiled stock is exceptionally fine with some scattered minor dings and scratches. Mechanically excellent. This is an outstanding example of a Civil War era production Henry rifle, which could easily become the centerpiece of even the most extensive collections of lever actions or antique American arms!
German Silver Mounted Antique Winchester Model 1873 Rifle
Lot # 3009 (Sale Order: 10 of 616)
Originally manufactured in 1886, this Winchester Model 1873 rifle shows attractive and very interesting period upgrades and embellishment, evoking the styles of an earlier period when American long rifles and half stock rifles ruled the frontier. During its period of use, the rifle was fitted with a heavy barrel that has a short octagonal section at the breech. The buttstock has been custom shaped, very much in line with those seen on the previously mentioned rifles, and has extensive, lightly engraved German silver mounts including an alligator, birds, and a stag head. There is a German silver patchbox on the right, a small cap box and cheekpiece on the left, and a lightly engraved long rifle type buttplate and toe plate. The barrel has no visible markings, and the bottom of the cartridge elevator is marked "44 CAL", with the serial number on the lower tang. It is fitted with a low German silver blade front sight and a notch rear sight in a dovetail on the octagonal section of the barrel. It is mounted with a smooth forearm and nicely figured straight grip stock with the previously mentioned mounts and cheekpiece, as well as a deep crescent buttplate.
Class: Antique
Very good as period customized, retains traces of period refinished blue mixed with dark grey and brown patina, some scattered light pitting, minor vise marks on the magazine tube, and mostly bright German silver. The wood is good with a few chips/slivers absent, a re-glued semi-circular crack visible at the rear of the tang, and typical minor handling marks. A very interesting Winchester Model 1873 rifle with both unique and attractive "old west" period customizations!
First Generation Colt Single Action Army Revolver
Lot # 3010 (Sale Order: 11 of 616)
Manufactured in 1915 in .38-40 WCF, one of those perfect cartridges for the Western frontier. As explained by Colt SAA expert and author David Brown, "This cartridge, as used in the Colt Single Action, made the revolver a perfect companion-piece for the Winchester .38-40 W.C.F. rifle--just as the .44-40 revolver was a mate for the .44-40 rifle. This bottle-neck .38-40 cartridge made one of the harder-hitting of the handgun loads, and hand-loaders today know that it can be reloaded to near the modern Magnum pressures" ("The 36 Calibers of the Colt Single Action Army," page 150). The barrel has the one-line Hartford address on top and "38 W.C.F." on the left side. The frame has the two-line patent date marking followed by a Rampant Colt on the left side. The left side of the trigger guard has the Colt factory triangle proof and the number "1." Matching serial numbers appear on the frame, trigger guard, and back strap. Fitted with a set of stag grips. Included is an extra set of highly attractive bone grips.
Class: Curio & Relic Handgun
Fine, retaining 50% original blue finish and 30% original case colors with a smooth brown patina on the balance and some pitting. The replacement grips are very fine. Mechanically excellent. A .38 WCF Colt SAA that shows authentic character of an early 20th century working gun.
Heiser Denver, Colorado "Bull's Head" Mexican Loop Holster Rig
Lot # 3011 (Sale Order: 12 of 616)
Trademarked in 1878 in Denver, Colorado, H.H. Heiser Saddlery produced a wide range of leather goods, including gun leather, well into the 20th century. This example shows one of their more iconic designs, featuring a bull's head prominently embossed on the holster loop. This bull's head design is pictured and discussed on p. 183-186 of "Packing Iron: Gunleather of the Frontier West" by Rattenbury, where he indicates that examples like this one were a continuation of an earlier design from the 1890s. The holster is configured for a right handed shooter and will accommodate a 4 3/4 inch barrel Colt Single Action Army Revolver. The Heiser maker's mark is present on the skirt of the holster and on the buckle billet of the belt. The belt is also marked "50" on the buckle billet, and the belt measures approximately 43 3/4 inches including the billet, which has been moved from its original location. This interesting belt features two pouches with snap secured flap closures and a single row of cartridge loops which accommodate .45 caliber cartridges (.50 were tried but do not fit). A belt with somewhat similar pouches is pictured on p. 172 of the previously mentioned book.
Class: Other
Very fine, both the holster and belt show some scattered light wear and marks from use and all of the stitching appearing to remain tight. The is a desirable Western holster with a cartridge belt in a rarely seen configuration!
Wostenholm & Son I-XL "The Hunters Companion" Bowie Knife
Lot # 3012 (Sale Order: 13 of 616)
Manufactured in the mid-late 1800s by the George Wostenholm firm of Sheffield, England. The Wostenholm company moved into their huge Washington Works facility around 1848, perfectly positioning themselves to deal with the demands of the American market which exploded during the period of western expansion and the Civil War. This massive example measures approximately 15 1/2 inches overall. The drop point blade measures 10 1/8 inches and has the Wostenholm Washington Works address, an eagle, The Hunters Companion, and I*XL markings all on the left side of the blade. It is fitted with an elliptical German silver guard, a stag antler grip with a slight curve, and a German silver cap on the pommel. Includes a red dyed sheath with gilt filled border decoration and I*XL marking, as well as German silver fittings at the tip and throat. Also includes an assortment of George Wostenholm & Sons advertising material.
Class: Other
Very fine, the crisp blade mostly bright with some scattered patches of patina/spotting and a few minor nicks in the edge. The German silver shows an attractive lightly aged patina. The grip is excellent with some light handling evidence. The sheath is fine with some mild wear and attractively aged patina on the fittings. A massive Wostenholm Bowie knife in fine condition that shows evidence of genuine period use!
Antique Winchester Model 1886 Lever Action Rifle in .50-100-450
Lot # 3013 (Sale Order: 14 of 616)
Manufactured in 1895, this is an exceptional example of Winchester's Model 1886 chambered in the most powerful big bore cartridge it was offered in. The .50/100/450 Express not only held a special place in the hearts of those on the frontier seeking a rifle that could stop anything, but has also remained highly sought after among Winchester collectors. Per Jim Paul and Tom Adams, only 331 Model 1886s left the Winchester factory chambered in .50-100-450 from 1894 to 1913 (See the article "Winchester Model 1886 Caliber 50-100-450"). With so few being made, there are hardly enough surviving Winchester "Big Fifty" Model 1886s to meet demand, with high condition examples like this one being even more scarce. These rifles had more than enough power to dispatch all large North American game as well as all but the most dangerous game in Africa, making them highly prized among big game hunters. Due to their popularity among frontier hunters, these big bore Winchesters are often seen in well-used condition, with very little finish remaining. This particular rifle is very obviously an exception to that rule. The included factory letter lists the serial number as applied on 15 June 1895. It shows that the rifle was in .50-100 caliber with an octagon barrel and plain trigger when received at the warehouse on 29 July 1895 and shipped on 14 August 1895 in order number 17900. The top barrel flat is marked with the two-line address and the caliber marking at the breech. The upper tang has the model marking and the lower tang is marked with the serial number. It is fitted with a German silver blade front sight and "1886" marked folding ladder rear sight, with factory index mark visible on the barrel in front of it. It is mounted with a smooth forearm and attractively figured straight grain and straight gripped stock with a crescent buttplate.
Class: Antique
Exceptionally fine, retaining 90% plus of the vibrant original case colors on the receiver having thinned to an even patina on portions of the lever and buttplate, 95% of the original blue finish remains on the barrel. The magazine tube appears to be an old refinish, and 60% of the bright original nitre blue on the loading gate. The wood is exceptionally fine with some scattered minor handling marks, concentrated on the left of the forearm. Mechanically excellent. Both an extremely rare and highly desirable example of an antique Winchester Model 1886 chambered in the elusive .50-100-450 Express caliber!
New Haven Arms Company Volcanic No. 1 Pocket Pistol
Lot # 3014 (Sale Order: 15 of 616)
This is one of only an estimated 850 Volcanic No. 1 lever action pocket pistols manufactured with a 3 1/2 inch barrel by the New Haven Arms Company in New Haven, Connecticut c. 1857-1862, per "Volcanic Firearms" (2011) by Lewis and Rutter, page 73. It has a non-engraved frame which is considered rarer. As Lewis and Rutter pointed out, "Engraved sideplates and frame were much more common on the small-frame pistol than were plain, polished frames even though the extra cost of engraving and plating was $1.50. Plain frames are very uncommon" (page 73). Volcanic firearms are historically significant and represent an important step in the development of American repeating firearms and self-contained cartridges. The lever action and integral spring-loaded magazine introduced with Volcanic pistols and carbines served as the basic design for the Henry rifle and the Winchester Model 1866, 1873 and 1876 rifles. Oliver Winchester's investment in the Volcanic Repeating Arms Company eventually led to the establishment of the Winchester Repeating Arms Company. The barrel is fitted with a pinched blade front sight and a simple notched rear sight is mounted in a dovetail on the frame. The two-line address "NEW HAVEN CONN./PATENT FEB. 14. 1854." is roll-stamped on top of the barrel. The deletion of "VOLCANIC" from the barrel legend occurred after Oliver Winchester formed the New Haven Arms Company on May 1, 1857. The serial number "36" appears on the right side of the lever, left side of the grip frame and on the back of the left grip panel.
Class: Antique
Fine, retains 60% plus original blue finish on the barrel with scattered freckling on the balance, attractive naturally aged untouched golden patina on the brass with tight sideplate joints, with much of the niter blue finish on the cartridge elevator, smooth gray and brown patina on the hammer and lever, with a crisp barrel address and distinct edges in the metal overall. Grips are very fine with most of the original piano varnish finish, some minor surface flaking along the lower edges, scattered light dents and scratches, defined edges and tight fitment. Mechanically excellent.
Smith & Wesson Volcanic No. 1 Lever Action Pistol
Lot # 3015 (Sale Order: 16 of 616)
This very scarce early repeating pistol is one of approximately 1,200 No. 1 pistols that were manufactured by Horace Smith and Daniel B. Wesson in Norwich, Connecticut, in 1854 and 1855. They are historically significant pieces for both Smith & Wesson and Winchester collectors as they marked Smith and Wesson's first business venture and are key pieces in the evolution of lever action firearms which developed into the famous Henry rifle and then Winchester's famous line of lever actions. The barrel has "CAST-STEEL" (right), "SMITH & WESSON/NORWICH. CT." (top) and "PATENT/FEB. 14. 1854." (left). Factory floral and scroll engraving is featured on the frame, side plates, and hammer. "352" is visible on the bottom of the action, left side of grip frame, and both grip panels.
Class: Antique
Fine. The barrel retains 60% original brown finish, strong traces of original blue remain on the frame in the protected areas, and some original case colors remain on the hammer, with a smooth gray patina on the balance. The engraving is crisp. The grips are also fine with minor handling marks and most of the original varnish remaining. The lever does not stay up, otherwise the action functions properly.
Provenance: The Charles Marx Collection
Documented One of One Thousand Winchester Model 1873 Rifle
Lot # 3016 (Sale Order: 17 of 616)
The included factory letter lists this rifle as a "1 of 1000" with an octagon barrel, set trigger, XXX checkered stock, sporting leaf sight, and casehardened finish and indicates it was received in the warehouse on November 1, 1875, and shipped the same day in order 4517. A repair and return date of December 8, 1900, in order 82556 is also listed. The rifle is listed in the charts of One of One Thousand Model 1873s drawn from the factory ledgers shown in Gordon's "Winchester's New Model of 1873: A Tribute, Volume II" on page 375 and on page 24 of "The Story of the Winchester 1 of 1000 and 1 of 100 Rifles" by Lewis. When the rifle was returned to Winchester it was apparently rebarreled and now has a heavier octagon barrel without the "One of One Thousand" inscription at the breech. It would be interesting to know why the rifle was rebarreled. Perhaps the owner shot it so much that he wore out the rifling. Since being returned from the factory, it evidently saw little to no use given the high condition. The barrel has a dovetailed blade front sight, the standard two-line address and patent marking, a dovetailed sporting rear sight, and "44 W.C.F." at the breech. The "First Model" frame has the "thumb print" dust cover riding in guide grooves in the frame and is equipped with a tang peep sight with "3" marked on the underside and has "MODEL. 1873." marked under the peep sight, "44 CAL." on the elevator, a single set trigger, and the script serial number on the lower tang. The highly figured XXX walnut forearm and straight wrist stock are checkered.
Class: Antique
Very fine as factory refurbished and re-barreled with 85% plus of the blue and casehardened finish remaining, minor wear mainly at the edges, and some minor pitting on the peep sight base. Aside from a chip on the front right top of the forearm, the wood is fine and displays stunning figure, crisp checkering, and mild scratches and dings. Mechanically excellent. This is certainly are rare and highly attractive Winchester Model 1873 and is documented as an original One of One Thousand!
Antique Casehardened Winchester Deluxe 1894 Lever Action Rifle
Lot # 3017 (Sale Order: 18 of 616)
This rifle was manufactured in 1895, the second year of production for the ever popular Winchester Model 1894, and has an incredibly rare combination of features, including the exceedingly rare casehardened frame, a variation few collectors have the opportunity of seeing let along acquiring. Robert C. Renneberg in "The Trilogy: Models 1894/94, 55, 64 (30th Anniversary Edition)" wrote that the casehardened receiver is the "most coveted of all on a Model 1894" and noted: "As of now I have only physically seen three verifiable case-colored examples," two of which were takedowns. There are 157 recorded in the factory records consisting of 155 rifles and 2 carbines (see pages 39-40). Survey data showed only 16 of those were ordered in deluxe configuration. The casehardening as a finish option was officially dropped by Winchester in 1901 leaving only a few years for casehardened Model 1894s to have been made. The number surviving is unknown, and we can go years without offering one at auction.This incredible example has casehardened finish on the frame, hammer, and lever and blued finish on the balance. It features a dovetailed front sight with a German silver blade, elevation adjustable dovetailed sporting rear sight, the two-line address ahead of the rear sight, "38-55" on top of the barrel at the breech, a tang mounted combination peep sight, plain trigger, style H checkered deluxe walnut forearm and pistol grip buttstock, and hard rubber grip cap and checkered shotgun buttplate embossed with the Winchester Repeating Arms Co.The included factory letter lists this early Winchester Model 1894 as a takedown rifle in .38/55 caliber with an octagon barrel, plain trigger, and a checkered pistol grip stock with shotgun butt and rubber buttplate. The casehardened finish is not listed, but we believe it to be authentic. The letter indicates the rifle was received in the warehouse on November 6, 1895, and shipped the same day. Additional included documentation confirms that David S. Madis received this rifle in a trade with the Buffalo Bill Historical Center, including a November 9, 1983, list signed by Curator Herbert G. Houze of the Winchester Arms Museum listing this rifle as the first of 16 firearms, including 13 other Winchester Model 1894s along with a Model 62A and a Garrett Arms Company Sharps carbine. The Winchester Arms Collection was loaned to the Buffalo Bill Historical Center in 1975. This rifle was thus traded out while the collection was in their possession but prior to the collection being gifted to the museum in 1988. The Winchester Arms Collection remains the core of the Cody Firearms Museum at the Buffalo Bill Center of the West.
Class: Antique
Fine with 60% original blue finish, 30% original case colors on the frame, 75% original case colors on the hammer and lever, silver-gray and brown patina on the balance, minor oxidation, and generally fairly minor overall wear. The refinished wood is also fine and has some small spots of wear in the otherwise crisp checkering, scattered scratches and dings, attractive figure, and a filled hole on the bottom of the butt from a sling swivel. Mechanically excellent. Do not miss your opportunity to get your hands on one of the rarest and most desirable Winchester Model 1894s!
Provenance: The Winchester Arms Collection; The David S. Madis Collection;Property of a Gentleman
Winchester Model 1876 Rifle with Full Nickel Finish
Lot # 3018 (Sale Order: 19 of 616)
Manufactured in 1880 this is a desirable example of a Winchester Model 1876 rifle that was special ordered with full nickel finish and a set trigger. The included factory letter lists the rifle with an octagon barrel, set trigger, and full nickel finish when received at the warehouse on 21 February 1880 and shipped the same day. According to noted Winchester historian and author George Madis, approximately one out of every 90 Model 1876s had a plated finish and one out of every 14 had a set trigger. This example has the second model receiver with the dust cover guide retained with two screws and the dust cover with the flush checkered "thumbprint" grip area. The top of the barrel has the standard two-line address and King's patent markings, and both the barrel and cartridge elevator correctly lack caliber markings .45-75 W.C.F. was originally the only caliber offered, with .45-60 and .50-95 being introduced just a year before this rifle was made. The upper tang has the model marking, and the serial number is marked on the lower tang. The assembly number "XXX 569" is marked on the left of the lower tang, with "569" repeated in the stock inlet and inside the buttplate. It is fitted with a German silver blade front sight, elevation adjustable notch rear sight, and the upper tang has a factory drilled and tapped hole for a peep sight with a filler screw in place. It is mounted with a very finely figured, smooth forearm and straight grip stock with a trapdoor crescent buttplate.
Class: Antique
Very good plus, with 30% of the original nickel finish remaining, mostly visible in sheltered areas and the balance a mixture of grey and brown patina. The wood is also very good with a minor split in the grain on the left of the buttstock and some scattered minor handling marks. Mechanically functions fine, although the set trigger does not work.
Colt First Generation Single Action Army Revolver
Lot # 3019 (Sale Order: 20 of 616)
Manufactured in 1899, this is a solid representative example of the iconic Colt Single Action Army revolver. The Single Action Army is considered one of the legendary firearms of the Western Frontier and has truly become a globally recognizable piece of Americana. Colt's Single Action Army was one of the most prolific sidearms during the late 19th century, when the "west was won", and continued its popularity in the region well into the 20th century, riding its reputation for simplicity and rugged dependability. This example is marked with the standard one-line address on top of the barrel and the caliber marking on the left. The left side of the frame is marked with the two-line patent dates, followed by the circled Rampant Colt. The matching serial number is marked on the bottom of the frame, trigger guard, and back strap. The assembly number "661" is marked inside the loading gate. It is fitted with the standard blade front and frame-top groove rear sight, as well as a pair of checkered hard rubber grips with Rampant Colts at the tops (unnumbered).
Class: Curio & Relic Handgun
Fine, retains 40% plus of the original blue finish and 25% of the original case colors with the balance having thinned to mostly a smooth grey patina in the form of mild handling/holster wear, typical of a frontier sidearm. The grips are also fine with a few light handling marks and some mild handling wear. Mechanically excellent. A standard configuration Colt Single Action Army that certainly looks like it may have seen the American West!
Provenance: The Collection of Ken Gibilisco
"Slim Jim/California" Single Action Army Revolver Holster
Lot # 3020 (Sale Order: 21 of 616)
Manufactured c. late 1870s to early 1880s, this is a desirable holster rig of the "Slim Jim" or "California" pattern, which were popular around the time the iconic Colt Single Action Army revolver burst onto the scene. This style of holster was popular for a couple decades prior to the release of the Single Action Army, but did not stay in fashion long before being usurped by the "Mexican Loop" styles, making surviving examples such as this very scarce. A very similar example to this one is pictured on p. 91 of "Packing Iron: Gunleather of the Frontier West" by Rattenbury. The holster shows tooled rosettes, a floral border, is marked "45" on the belt loop, and has a sewn in toe. It is configured for a right handed shooter and will accommodate a revolver with a 7 1/2 inch barrel. Included with the holster is a 2 inch wide cartridge belt with a single row of .44/.45 caliber loops and a California clipped nickeled buckle. The belt is hand marked very faintly with a name and "Denver/Colo." on the front near the billet. It measures 41 1/4 inches overall including the billet.
Class: Other
Very good, the holster showing moderate wear, some minor age cracking, some scuffs, and some of the tooling softened. The cartridge belt is also fine with some light age cracking, some minor scuffs, and the buckle billet a later replacement. A desirable holster from early in the period of the legendary Colt Single Action Army revolver!
George Woodhead Sheffield Bowie Knife with Lion Pommel
Lot # 3021 (Sale Order: 22 of 616)
The George Woodhead firm was in operation under his name alone from 1849 to 1875 at 36 Howard Street in Sheffield, before later becoming known as George Woodhead & Sons. Like most Sheffield knife maker's, Woodhead's largest market would have been in the United States, especially during the Civil War and westward expansion. It measures 11 5/8 inches overall with a 7 3/8 inch clip point blade marked "G. WOODHEAD/36 HOWARD STREET/SHEFFIELD" on the left ricasso. The elliptical guard is German silver. The coffin shaped grip has a cast silver lion "dormant" pommel and smooth pearl grip scales with a blank German silver escutcheon on the left. The included sheath is of dark brown leather with faint gilt floral motifs and German silver fittings.
Class: Other
Very good, the blade mostly a bright grey patina with scattered light pitting throughout, moderate wear from use, and clear markings. The German silver is lightly aged and bright. The grips are fine with a minor crack in the right panel. The sheath is good with moderate wear and a partially separated seam. An attractive knife from one of Sheffield's most desirable makers!
Buffalo Bill's Wild West Shipped Winchester Model 1873 Rifle
Lot # 3022 (Sale Order: 23 of 616)
Manufactured in 1908, this is an example of what appears to be a standard configuration Winchester Model 1873 rifle, however the final shipping destination and configuration of this specific rifle are anything but standard. The included factory letter lists the rifle in .44 caliber with an octagon smoothbore barrel when received in the warehouse on 23 September 1909, shipped the same day to Buffalo Bill's Wild West in Shawnee, Oklahoma, and charged to Cody, Bailey, and Lillie of New York. Winchester Model 1873 rifles with factory smoothbore barrels are very scarce despite their popularity with exhibition shooters around the turn of the century. On p. 549 of "Winchester's New Model of 1873 A Tribute Vol. II" by James D. Gordon, he lists only eight known examples verified by factory ledgers out of the 3,800 guns surveyed. If those numbers are extrapolated out over the total production of 730,000 Model 1873s, it equates to approximately 0.2% of total production being made with factory smoothbore barrels. The organization this rifle was charged to was the partnership between William F. "Buffalo Bill" Cody, James A. Bailey of Barnum & Bailey circus fame, and Gordon W. "Pawnee Bill" Lillie. Bailey had died in 1906 and his family took over his stake in the Wild West Show, however, according to a letter from Cody to George T. Beck in 1909, it appears that their stake was bought out by Cody and Lillie, news that may not have reached Winchester by the time this rifle shipped. It was around 1909 that Buffalo Bill's show, which had run since 1883, combined with Pawnee Bill's to form a new and larger show which was called "Buffalo Bill’s Wild West and Pawnee Bill’s Far East", but was more commonly referred to as "Two Bills Show". The new combined show included all the expected "Wild West" attractions such as Native Americans, cowboys, Mexican Vaqueros, and frontier wildlife, while adding in acts from all over the world including India, Australia, Russia, Scotland, and Japan. A rifle such as this one would have been ordered by the show for an exhibition shooter, particularly for "trap shooting" things such as glass or resin balls thrown into the air. These smoothbore shotguns fooled the crowds who believed these incredible shooters were hitting their targets with standard rifle cartridges, making their feats seem much more impressive. During its existence, the show featured performances by people who are forever synonymous with the Western frontier and include such notables as Buck Taylor "King of the Cowboys," Annie Oakley, Frank Butler, Sitting Bull, Johnny Baker "The Cowboy Kid," Rough Rider Billy McGinty, Pawnee Bill, Dr. William Frank Carver, Montana Frank and Calamity Jane. Wild West shows such as the "Two Bills Show" were an extremely popular form of entertainment around the turn of the century and played a pivotal role in cementing the legacy of America's Western Frontier, long after the west itself had been tamed. This rifle would have been present for the final acts of this legendary show, which continued until 1913 when financial struggles and some malicious business dealings brought the show to an end. After a few years of shuffling around to different circuses and shows, the legendary Buffalo Bill Cody died in 1917.The rifle itself, being manufactured in 1908, has the third model receiver which features the integral dust cover guide and the dust cover with gripping serrations at the rear. The top of the barrel and receiver have Winchester factory oval proofs stamped at the breech. The top barrel flat is marked with the two-line address and King's patent marking, and the caliber is marked on the upper left flat at the breech. The bottom of the cartridge elevator does not appear to have ever been marked with the caliber. The upper tang is marked with the three-line model and trademark designation, and the serial number is marked on the lower tang. The left side of the lower tang is marked "794", but the number is not repeated on the buttstock or buttplate. It is fitted with a set of "sporting sights" featuring a German silver blade front and elevation adjustable buckhorn rear (elevator a later replacement), and the upper tang has two factory drilled and tapped holes for a peep sight with filler screws in place. It is mounted with a smooth forearm and straight grip stock with a trapdoor crescent buttplate (grip knob for trapdoor absent).
Class: Curio & Relic Long Gun
Good, showing mostly a grey patina with some scattered light surface pitting, typical of a gun that saw the use of the Western Frontier by portraying it theatrically. The rear sight elevator is a later replacement. The wood shows all the typic
more...
Savage Model 1907 Pistol Inscribed to Showman Pawnee Bill
Lot # 3023 (Sale Order: 24 of 616)
Manufactured in 1911. All Savage factory engraved pistols are rare. Those also inscribed to famed American Wild West showmen are incredibly rare. Per Stern’s "10 Shots Quick: The Fascinating Story of the Savage Pocket Automatics," Wild West showman Buffalo Bill ordered five Savage pistols engraved with the names of some of his friends (pages 82-83). RIAC had the pleasure of selling a pistol inscribed to Buffalo Bill (no. 33177) in September 2021. Now, we have a Savage pistol inscribed to another famed Wild West showman: Gordon William “Pawnee Bill†Lillie (1860-1942). While this pistol is not among the five listed by Stern as ordered by Buffalo Bill, it stands as a historic piece of Savage and Wild West memorabilia. Lillie worked as an interpreter on the Pawnee Indian Agency which earned him the nickname “Pawnee Bill.†In 1883, he became an interpreter and performer in "Buffalo Bill’s Wild West." In 1888, he and his wife, May, started "Pawnee Bill’s Historic Wild West" which became "Pawnee Bill’s Historical Wild West, Indian Museum and Encampment" and later "Pawnee Bill’s Wild West and Great Far East Show.†In 1908, Pawnee Bill joined Buffalo Bill to create the "Buffalo Bill's Wild West and Pawnee Bill's Great Far East," often called the "Two Bills Show." The pistol features Savage A or Protector Grade factory engraving. The modest coverage clearly exhibits the English style scrollwork of Savage’s Master Engraver Enoch Tue. This style of engraving was the most basic type of Savage’s pistol engraving patterns and was commonly offered at an additional charge of $12.50 above the $15 price for a non-engraved pistol. The gun is personalized with the inscription “MAJOR G.W. LILLIE†on the left side of the frame just above the grip panel. The accompanying factory letter confirms the factory A engraving and "name engraved on left side of frame" when it was sold to Major G.W. Lillie, accepted on October 28, 1911, and shipped on November 2, 1911. Savage used celebrity endorsements in its advertising for the Model 1907. The endorsements came from Buffalo Bill, William â€Bat†Masterson, detective William Pinkerton, and detective W.J. Burns who “prefer[ed] the Savage Automatic for its speed and accuracy.†“The unanimous choice of these men may be safely backed against the world,†proclaimed the Savage booklet “It Banishes Fear!†This was after all “the greatest weapon ever invented for the protection of the home.†Use of celebrity endorsements ramped up in 1911. Savage often provided the endorser with a free gun(s) and/or payment. Perhaps this pistol was presented by Savage to Pawnee Bill in an attempt to win over his endorsement. The engraving on Buffalo Bill's pistol presented to him by Savage in 1911 is very similar to the engraving on this Model 1907.
Class: Curio & Relic Handgun
Exceptionally fine, retaining 80% bright original blue finish with the balance thinning to brown. The engraving is crisp. The grips are excellent with a few minor handling marks and overall crisp checkering. Mechanically excellent. This factory engraved Savage Model 1907 is a great piece of Savage and Wild West heritage.
Engraved & W.H. Tucker Inscribed Winchester Model 1873 Rifle
Lot # 3024 (Sale Order: 25 of 616)
This is an incredibly rare special order factory engraved Winchester Model 1873. The included factory letter lists this rifle in .32 caliber with an octagon barrel, set trigger, checkered pistol grip stock, $2.50 engraving, gilt trim, balance nickel, and name engraved on the side plate. It was received in the warehouse on November 22, 1883, and shipped the same day in order 8792. The barrel is equipped with a dovetailed front sight base with a bead style brass blade and a dovetailed sporting rear sight and is marked with the two-line address and patent marking ahead of the rear sight and the caliber designation "32- CAL" at the breech, and "32/CAL" is also marked on the cartridge elevator. The action has the Third Model dust cover and integral guide rail and is equipped with an adjustable single set trigger. The model marking with foliate accents is marked on the upper tang. The rifle is fitted with a deluxe walnut forearm and pistol grip stock with checkering, contrasting inlay in the grip, and a rifle buttplate. The forend cap, frame, elevator, and buttplate display classic Ulrich pattern scroll engraving and includes a dog's head on the right side plate, and the left side plate is inscribed "W.H. Tucker/North Platte,/Neb." In "Winchester's New Model of 1873: A Tribute, Volume II," James D. Gordon wrote that "personal inscriptions on Model 1873s are quite rare, particularly when authenticated in the warehouse ledgers." He further noted, "Sometimes, factory inscriptions will be made on guns that are fully engraved, but that is not usually the case." His survey found only 82 rifles with personal inscriptions, including 66 rifles. This rifle was not one of those included on his survey list. This rifle was reportedly gifted by William "Buffalo Bill" Cody who also ordered serial number 121153 which was factory engraved and inscribed "Presented by Buffalo Bill (W.F. Cody)/to/Robbie Campbell Adams/1883" and shipped in 1883. That rifle was sold at auction by Rock Island Auction Company in September 2016.We found the rifle discussed in the Omaha Daily Bee on November 28, 1883, in the article titled "A SPLENDID GUN: Made by the Winchester Arms Company for a North Platte Man." The paper states: "When Mr. A. G. McAusland, the agent of the Winchester Repeating Arms company was in Omaha about a month ago, he received from Collins & Petty, the agents in this part of the west for that company, an order for a fine 32 calibre Winchester rifle, patent of 1873, for W. H. Tucker, of North Platte, Nebraska. Mr. McAusland Monday arrived in Omaha with the gun and turned it over to Collins & Petty. It is certainly one of the handsomest rifles ever made in this country. It is silver-plated, with gold trimmings, is handsomely engraved, and has all the late improvements. The cost was $100." The same day, the paper also reported Tucker shooting 99 our of 100 clay pigeons with Mayor Buck, John Hancock, Dell Huntington, and other friends as witnesses. In 1883, Andrew McAusland also notably sent one of John Browning's single shot rifles back to the company ultimately leading to the purchase of the design and Browning's influence on Winchester's lever action rifles.Other newspaper reports from 1883 when the rifle was shipped gave other news concerning Tucker, including that he received another inscribed rifle. The Columbus Telegram on December 22, 1883, wrote: "On Thursday of this week W.H. Tucker received a new and beautiful Colt's patent repeating rifle as a present from Dr. C. H. Bullock of Hartford, Conn., who was the Guest of Hon. and Mrs. William Cody this fall, and is recognized as one of the leading sportsman [sic] of the east. The rifle bears the following inscription: 'To William H. Tucker, from Dr. C. H. Bullock, in remembrance of our hunt on the plains.' It is needless to say that Tucker is very proud of his beautiful present." He must have been very proud of his flashy nickel and gold Winchester as well. Given it shipped in the fall of 1883, perhaps it was a gift of Buffalo Bill to Tucker for the hunt with Bullock.The rifle is accompanied by consignor research on William H. Tucker (1843-1886). This research along with our own paints the picture of quite the western character. He was born in Iowa and served in the 6th Iowa Infantry and the 4th Iowa Cavalry during the Civil War. After the war, he headed west to Nebraska. There he became a noted gambler and gunman and purchased the OK Saloon in Ogallala in the late 1870s and renamed it the Cowboy's Rest Saloon. He was noted as a tall, attractive man who adopted a similar style as Buffalo Bill Cody. Buffa
more... Provenance: The Ralph Cindrich Collection; The Charles Marx Collection