Lost Collection of Mr Hall Coin Pt 2 Auction 44MA

Lost Collection of Mr Hall Coin Pt 2 Auction 44MA

Monday, November 10, 2025  |  1:30 PM Eastern
Auction closed.
Lost Collection of Mr Hall Coin Pt 2 Auction 44MA

Lost Collection of Mr Hall Coin Pt 2 Auction 44MA

Monday, November 10, 2025  |  1:30 PM Eastern
Auction closed.
Internet Premium: 18%
See Special Terms for additional fees
Cash Payment Discount: 3%
Share:

Description

They were lost in the Wall.

The Collection that was almost never found.

The Lost Coins finally uncovered.

KDC Online Coin Auctions Proudly presents part 2 of The Lost Coin Collection of Theadore Hall.

The Hall family reached out to us to appraise and consign a rare collection of coins put together by the late Mr. Hall. The backstory on this collection was so incredible we couldn’t not share it with you.

Theadore hall was a private contractor for over 40 years. With a passion for coin collecting he shared with all those around him, his family knew he was sitting on quite the collection.

However, after he passed, his family could not locate the collection he had frequently boasted about. They had his house emptied, they reached out to anyone they could think of who might have known where he stored the collection, they tried to see if there were any Safety Deposit boxes in his name, but they never had any luck.

After months of hunting, his house was eventually sold and the collection remained a mystery. Almost...
Show more

Key Date Coins



(856) 685-9848
Need help with bidding? Get Help
Catalog Terms of sale
Search Catalog :
Sort By :
Go to Lot :
Go to Page :
Per Page :
Pg : 1 of 45

WELCOME TO THE AUCTION

Lot # 1 (Sale Order: 1 of 1115)      

Just to Reiterate from our terms and conditions: I do my best to estimate the grade/condition of the coins, but please note, unless specifically mentioned in the descrip...moretion, I do not guarantee grade or condition. I DO ALWAYS GUARANTEE 100% AUTHENTICITY, on an immediate buyback including any premium paid. But please understand, if you win a coin and receive it and send it out to one of the grading companies and it comes back graded less than I estimated or "genuine but Ungradeable", we will not buy back that coin. No refunds will be issued. Please understand this and look at the large pictures and make your own decision on the grade/condition. I do my best to give you my best estimate and your repeat attendance at my auctions is what I strive for, so I always attempt to give my best description/estimate of the coins being auctioned.

Bid Not Accepted!

Bid Accepted!

You've been outbid!

PASSED

You've been outbid  to YOU!

This lot was not sold.

Placing your bid. please wait...

Reserve Not Met

1878-p 7tf Morgan Dollar Colorfully Toned TOP POP! $1 ms67 SEGS

Lot # 11441 (Sale Order: 2 of 1115)      

1878-p 7tf Colorfully Toned TOP POP! Morgan Dollar $1 ms67 SEGS....more

Bid Not Accepted!

Bid Accepted!

You've been outbid!

Sold for: USD 1,100.00

You've been outbid  to onsite! to YOU!

Placing your bid. please wait...

1934 $100 Green Seal Federal Reserve Note Chicago, IL Grades xf+

Lot # 11442 (Sale Order: 3 of 1115)      

1934 $100 Green Seal Federal Reserve Note Chicago, IL Grades xf+....more

Bid Not Accepted!

Bid Accepted!

You've been outbid!

Sold for: USD 225.00

You've been outbid  to onsite! to YOU!

Placing your bid. please wait...

1908-p Gold Indian Quarter Eagle $2 1/2 ms64+ SEGS

Lot # 11443 (Sale Order: 4 of 1115)      

1908-p Gold Indian Quarter Eagle $2 1/2 ms64+ SEGS. A Key Date's Pick, Bid to Win Coin...more

Bid Not Accepted!

Bid Accepted!

You've been outbid!

Sold for: USD 1,300.00

You've been outbid  to onsite! to YOU!

Placing your bid. please wait...

1917 Standing Liberty Quarter Type 1 & Type 2 Coin Set, 2 Coins

Lot # 11444 (Sale Order: 5 of 1115)      

1917 Standing Liberty Quarter Type 1 & Type 2 Coin Set, 2 Coins. Many numismatists hailed Hermon A. MacNeil's classically inspired Standing Liberty silver quarter ...moredesign as one of the finest ever seen. Some, however, were outraged because Liberty's right breast was exposed. In response, the mint altered the design partway through 1917 by covering up Liberty in chain mail!These extremely popular 2-coin sets contain the much sought-after "t" 1917 Type 1 Standing Liberty quarter, plus the more modest Type 2 version. This unique coin set is such a numismatic classic, even collectors not specializing in quarters want them for their own collections!

Bid Not Accepted!

Bid Accepted!

You've been outbid!

Sold for: USD 130.00

You've been outbid  to J****l! to YOU!

Placing your bid. please wait...

1921-p Buffalo Nickel 5c Grades au58

Lot # 11447 (Sale Order: 6 of 1115)      

1921-p Buffalo Nickel 5c Grades au58....more

Bid Not Accepted!

Bid Accepted!

You've been outbid!

Sold for: USD 180.00

You've been outbid  to onsite! to YOU!

Placing your bid. please wait...

Circulated 10 Coin SEARS Peace Silver Dollar $1 Roll 1925/1926 Ends

Lot # 11448 (Sale Order: 7 of 1115)      

Circulated 10 Coin SEARS Peace Silver Dollar $1 Roll 1925/1926 Ends. Up For Auction is a 31- Circulated 10 Coin SEARS Peace Silver Dollar $1 Roll 1925/1926 Ends ...moreRoll Weighing 223.3 g Based On this weight this is a Circ Roll We are very excited to present over 1,500 Silver Dollar Rolls from what we are calling “The Department Store Hoard”. Inside this hoard was a huge estate of hundreds of silver dollar rolls. The sheer size of it was unprecedented. Throughout the early-mid 1900’s the collector of the estate acquired hundreds of coin rolls of all different types. His family tells us that he was at one point a buyer for Macys and then a suit wholesaler to various department stores. While in these stores he would often pick up “investment rolls” at a lower price than they were offering the public. In his collection, we found original numismatic advertisements, catalogs, newspapers, and magazines from a wide array of places used to order these rolls and various other coins in his collection.There were 10-15 different types of roll’s in this collection. However, the vast majority were stamped “Gimbels, Marshall Field, and Sears”. Among this collection are 10 and 20 coin rolls. The Sears rolls have a special place in Corey’s heart as he fondly recalls his father taking him to the Sears in Long Island to buy coins. The sears rolls all have open ends. From what we have found there were both Morgan and Peace Rolls, some being mixed. The mixed rolls have an “M” stamped on the wrapper. We photographed one roll from each type of end that we found that best represented each date. The roll you will receive is comparable or better then the one in the photo. We did this to be able to get you these rolls to you every week or (until they run out). We have spent months going through this collection and identifying everything. We have opened several rolls of every type and did not find any that were miss marked. Based on all of our findings and what we have found when we opened various rolls, we have estimated the values of what we believe each variation tends to have.There were a lot of rolls in this hoard and the different kinds are quite confusing, Corey has made a PDF explaining each variety and what he has found in a bit more depth. If you are interested in a copy, send us an email at jordan@kdcauction.com and we’ll send one right over.The agreement with the Consignee is that we wire on Friday their portion of the funds for any rolls paid that week and on Mondays we will send our runner up to New York to retrieve the rolls for shipment that week from our offices as well as photographing the rolls for the next week's auction. We hope you enjoy these rolls as much as we have bringing them to you.

Bid Not Accepted!

Bid Accepted!

You've been outbid!

Sold for: USD 600.00

You've been outbid  to onsite! to YOU!

Placing your bid. please wait...

1878-s Morgan Dollar $1 Grades ms62

Lot # 11449 (Sale Order: 8 of 1115)      

1878-s Morgan Dollar $1 Grades ms62. Slightly better date. First year of issue....more

Bid Not Accepted!

Bid Accepted!

You've been outbid!

PASSED

You've been outbid ! to YOU!

This lot was not sold.

Placing your bid. please wait...

Reserve Not Met

1951-d Franklin Half Dollar 50c Grades ms65+

Lot # 11451 (Sale Order: 9 of 1115)      

1951-d Franklin Half Dollar 50c Grades ms65+....more

Bid Not Accepted!

Bid Accepted!

You've been outbid!

Sold for: USD 80.00

You've been outbid  to onsite! to YOU!

Placing your bid. please wait...

1909 VDB Lincoln Cent Near Top Pop 1c ms66+ rb SEGS

Lot # 11455 (Sale Order: 10 of 1115)      

1909 VDB Near Top Pop Lincoln Cent 1c ms66+ rb SEGS. Always sought after date. Always popular....more

Bid Not Accepted!

Bid Accepted!

You've been outbid!

Sold for: USD 130.00

You've been outbid  to u****c! to YOU!

Placing your bid. please wait...

2000-2024 25 Proof Set Run - 292 Coins, 25 Complete Sets Comeplete 21st century Set

Lot # 11456 (Sale Order: 11 of 1115)      

2000-2024 25 Proof Set Run - 292 Coins, 25 Complete Sets Comeplete 21st century Set. 2000-2024 25 Years Modern Proof Set Run - 292 Coins, 25 Complete Sets. The 200...more9 mint and proof sets had the highest number of coins and highest face value of any standard mint and proof sets issued, as they included 5 varieties of dollar coin, 6 varieties of quarter, and 4 varieties of lincoln cents.

Bid Not Accepted!

Bid Accepted!

You've been outbid!

Sold for: USD 900.00

You've been outbid  to onsite! to YOU!

Placing your bid. please wait...

1879-s Morgan Dollar $1 Grades ms62

Lot # 11457 (Sale Order: 12 of 1115)      

1879-s Morgan Dollar $1 Grades ms62....more

Bid Not Accepted!

Bid Accepted!

You've been outbid!

Sold for: USD 70.00

You've been outbid  to onsite! to YOU!

Placing your bid. please wait...

1852-p Gold Liberty Quarter Eagle $2 1/2 ms62+ USCG

Lot # 11459 (Sale Order: 13 of 1115)      

1852-p Gold Liberty Quarter Eagle $2 1/2 ms62+ USCG....more

Bid Not Accepted!

Bid Accepted!

You've been outbid!

Sold for: USD 1,000.00

You've been outbid  to onsite! to YOU!

Placing your bid. please wait...

10 Coin Silver Dollar $1 Roll Peace UNC From SEARS 1924/1922 Ends

Lot # 11460 (Sale Order: 14 of 1115)      

10 Coin Silver Dollar $1 Roll Peace UNC From SEARS 1924/1922 Ends. Up For Auction is a 15- 10 Coin Silver Dollar $1 Roll Peace UNC From SEARS 1924/1922 Ends Roll...more Weighing 270.5 g Based On this weight this is a UNC Roll We are very excited to present over 1,500 Silver Dollar Rolls from what we are calling “The Department Store Hoard”. Inside this hoard was a huge estate of hundreds of silver dollar rolls. The sheer size of it was unprecedented. Throughout the early-mid 1900’s the collector of the estate acquired hundreds of coin rolls of all different types. His family tells us that he was at one point a buyer for Macys and then a suit wholesaler to various department stores. While in these stores he would often pick up “investment rolls” at a lower price than they were offering the public. In his collection, we found original numismatic advertisements, catalogs, newspapers, and magazines from a wide array of places used to order these rolls and various other coins in his collection.There were 10-15 different types of roll’s in this collection. However, the vast majority were stamped “Gimbels, Marshall Field, and Sears”. Among this collection are 10 and 20 coin rolls. The Sears rolls have a special place in Corey’s heart as he fondly recalls his father taking him to the Sears in Long Island to buy coins. The sears rolls all have open ends. From what we have found there were both Morgan and Peace Rolls, some being mixed. The mixed rolls have an “M” stamped on the wrapper. We photographed one roll from each type of end that we found that best represented each date. The roll you will receive is comparable or better then the one in the photo. We did this to be able to get you these rolls to you every week or (until they run out). We have spent months going through this collection and identifying everything. We have opened several rolls of every type and did not find any that were miss marked. Based on all of our findings and what we have found when we opened various rolls, we have estimated the values of what we believe each variation tends to have.There were a lot of rolls in this hoard and the different kinds are quite confusing, Corey has made a PDF explaining each variety and what he has found in a bit more depth. If you are interested in a copy, send us an email at jordan@kdcauction.com and we’ll send one right over.The agreement with the Consignee is that we wire on Friday their portion of the funds for any rolls paid that week and on Mondays we will send our runner up to New York to retrieve the rolls for shipment that week from our offices as well as photographing the rolls for the next week's auction. We hope you enjoy these rolls as much as we have bringing them to you.

Bid Not Accepted!

Bid Accepted!

You've been outbid!

Sold for: USD 750.00

You've been outbid  to onsite! to YOU!

Placing your bid. please wait...

1941-p Walking Liberty Half Dollar 50c Grades ms65+

Lot # 11463 (Sale Order: 15 of 1115)      

1941-p Walking Liberty Half Dollar 50c Grades ms65+....more

Bid Not Accepted!

Bid Accepted!

You've been outbid!

Sold for: USD 140.00

You've been outbid  to onsite! to YOU!

Placing your bid. please wait...

1991 United States Mint Prestige Proof Set 6 Coins W/ Box & COA

Lot # 11464 (Sale Order: 16 of 1115)      

1991 United States Mint Prestige Proof Set 6 Coins W/ Box & COA. Product DetailsThis wonderful seven-piece set includes all of the proof issue coins of 1991 as wel...morel as a commemorative Mount Rushmore clad half dollar and Silver dollar in the original U.S. Mint presentation case.Product Highlights: Commemorative dollar is struck in 90% Silver, with .7734 oz of actual Silver weight. Each Prestige Set will come in its original box, and may or may not include a certificate of authenticity. Set includes a proof example of the following coins: Lincoln Cent, Jefferson Nickel, Roosevelt Dime, Washington Quarter, Kennedy Half Dollar and a commemorative Mount Rushmore Silver dollar and clad half dollar. mirrorlike Proof finish adds further beauty with an impressive shine.

Bid Not Accepted!

Bid Accepted!

You've been outbid!

Sold for: USD 70.00

You've been outbid  to onsite! to YOU!

Placing your bid. please wait...

1881-s Morgan Dollar $1 Grades ms62

Lot # 11465 (Sale Order: 17 of 1115)      

1881-s Morgan Dollar $1 Grades ms62....more

Bid Not Accepted!

Bid Accepted!

You've been outbid!

Sold for: USD 70.00

You've been outbid  to onsite! to YOU!

Placing your bid. please wait...

1928 $10 Gold Certificate Signatures Woods/Mellon Grades Select AU

Lot # 11466 (Sale Order: 18 of 1115)      

1928 $10 Gold Certificate Signatures Woods/Mellon Grades Select AU. FR-2400 Alexander Hamilton is the central subject of this scarce $10 gold note, issued because of a c...morehange in the size of United States currency beginning with all series dated 1928. This change in the size of America’s currency came about from a study that had determined that printing smaller currency would save the government a hefty amount of money in production cost. Because of the nature of gold certificates – each one accompanied the deposit of gold coins – they are somewhat scarce to begin with, as gold is far more scarce than silver. Add to that the decision to drop the gold standard by President Franklin D. Roosevelt in 1933, thus making owning gold coin (or notes promising gold coin) illegal, and you end up with a series of notes that was printed, then recalled less than six years after their initial issue. Many of the notes were destroyed when turned in, and few of them survived. Fortunately for collectors, the restriction for owning gold certificates as collectibles was repealed by Treasury Secretary C. Douglas Dillon in 1964, but the damage had been done to the stockpiles of said notes. Not many remain of the millions that had originally been issued prior to the depression.

Bid Not Accepted!

Bid Accepted!

You've been outbid!

Sold for: USD 400.00

You've been outbid  to onsite! to YOU!

Placing your bid. please wait...

1925-d Gold Indian Quarter Eagle $2 1/2 ms65+ SEGS

Lot # 11467 (Sale Order: 19 of 1115)      

1925-d Gold Indian Quarter Eagle $2 1/2 ms65+ SEGS. A Key Date's Pick, Bid to Win, Don't let it get Away Coin...more

Bid Not Accepted!

Bid Accepted!

You've been outbid!

Sold for: USD 1,200.00

You've been outbid  to u****o! to YOU!

Placing your bid. please wait...

1999-2008 Full Mint Set Run - 220 Coins, 10 Complete Sets 10 Complete Sets

Lot # 11468 (Sale Order: 20 of 1115)      

1999-2008 Full Mint Set Run - 220 Coins, 10 Complete Sets 10 Complete Sets. 1999-2008 50 State Quarters Full Mint Set Run - 220 Coins, 10 Complete Sets. This group...more of mint sets includes all 50 State Quarters, 5 states per set across 10 sets.

Bid Not Accepted!

Bid Accepted!

You've been outbid!

Sold for: USD 150.00

You've been outbid  to onsite! to YOU!

Placing your bid. please wait...

1961 Proof Franklin Half Dollar Near Top Pop! 50c pr68+ DCAM SEGS

Lot # 11469 (Sale Order: 21 of 1115)      

1961 Near Top Pop! Franklin Half Dollar 50c pr68+ DCAM SEGS....more

Bid Not Accepted!

Bid Accepted!

You've been outbid!

Sold for: USD 225.00

You've been outbid  to onsite! to YOU!

Placing your bid. please wait...

1927-p Buffalo Nickel 5c Grades ms65+

Lot # 11471 (Sale Order: 22 of 1115)      

1927-p Buffalo Nickel 5c Grades ms65+....more

Bid Not Accepted!

Bid Accepted!

You've been outbid!

Sold for: USD 170.00

You've been outbid  to onsite! to YOU!

Placing your bid. please wait...

GIMBLES Unc Morgan Silver Dollar $1 Roll C 10 Coin

Lot # 11472 (Sale Order: 23 of 1115)      

GIMBLES Unc Morgan Silver Dollar $1 Roll C 10 Coin. Up For Auction is a 149- GIMBLES Unc Morgan Silver Dollar $1 Roll C 10 Coin Roll Weighing 270 g Based On this...more weight this is a UNC Roll We are very excited to present over 1,500 Silver Dollar Rolls from what we are calling “The Department Store Hoard”. Inside this hoard was a huge estate of hundreds of silver dollar rolls. The sheer size of it was unprecedented. Throughout the early-mid 1900’s the collector of the estate acquired hundreds of coin rolls of all different types. His family tells us that he was at one point a buyer for Macys and then a suit wholesaler to various department stores. While in these stores he would often pick up “investment rolls” at a lower price than they were offering the public. In his collection, we found original numismatic advertisements, catalogs, newspapers, and magazines from a wide array of places used to order these rolls and various other coins in his collection.There were 10-15 different types of roll’s in this collection. However, the vast majority were stamped “Gimbels, Marshall Field, and Sears”. Among this collection are 10 and 20 coin rolls. Most of the covered end rolls are marked “Morgan, Peace, or Mixed”. The Gimbels rolls are marked “A+, A, B+, B, and C” and stamped on one of the ends “M” or “P” designating Morgans or Peace Dollars. We believe more than this variety existed at some point, but these are the only markings that we found in this collection. After opening several of each type, we have determined that the letters seem to refer to the rarity and quality of the coins inside. We have spent months going through this collection and identifying everything. We have opened several rolls of every type and did not find any that were miss marked. Based on all of our findings and what we have found when we opened various rolls, we have estimated the values of what we believe each variation tends to have.There were a lot of rolls in this hoard and the different kinds are quite confusing, Corey has made a PDF explaining each variety and what he has found in a bit more depth. If you are interested in a copy, send us an email at jordan@kdcauction.com and we’ll send one right over.The agreement with the Consignee is that we wire on Friday their portion of the funds for any rolls paid that week and on Mondays we will send our runner up to New York to retrieve the rolls for shipment that week from our offices as well as photographing the rolls for the next week's auction. We hope you enjoy these rolls as much as we have bringing them to you!

Bid Not Accepted!

Bid Accepted!

You've been outbid!

Sold for: USD 1,000.00

You've been outbid  to onsite! to YOU!

Placing your bid. please wait...

1882-o Morgan Dollar $1 Grades ms64

Lot # 11473 (Sale Order: 24 of 1115)      

1882-o Morgan Dollar $1 Grades ms64....more

Bid Not Accepted!

Bid Accepted!

You've been outbid!

Sold for: USD 90.00

You've been outbid  to onsite! to YOU!

Placing your bid. please wait...

1923 $1 United States Note Grades Select AU Signatures Speelman/White

Lot # 11474 (Sale Order: 25 of 1115)      

1923 $1 United States Note Grades Select AU Signatures Speelman/White. Signatures of Speelman and White. The last of the large-sized U.S. $1 notes! Take a dollar bill ou...moret of your wallet and give it a look. You’ll see George Washington occupying his familiar place on the front of the bill. Now imagine that note larger, with a bright red seal and serial number, and an attractive “cogwheel” design on the back. The red coloring lights this note up like a safety flare! And the size…. Wow! That’s what’s in store for you when you secure this 1923 Red Seal Note. The 1923 $1 legal tender note is the successor to the series of 1917 issues.

Bid Not Accepted!

Bid Accepted!

You've been outbid!

Sold for: USD 600.00

You've been outbid  to onsite! to YOU!

Placing your bid. please wait...

Search Catalog :
Sort By :
Go to Lot :
Go to Page :
Per Page :
Pg : 1 of 45

1.178.0.2392.f3538cf.11.8